especially Jer. ii. 12. “Be astonished, O ye heavens, at this.” So Isa. i. 2-4. “Hear, O heavens,
and give ear, O earth; I have nourished and brought up children, and they have rebelled
against me. The ox knoweth his owner, and the ass his master’s crib; but my people doth
not know, Israel doth not consider. Ah, sinful nation! a people laden with iniquity, a seed
of evil-doers, children that are corrupters.” (Compare Deut. xxxii. 6-19.) If to be disposed
thus to abuse the blessings of so fruitful and pleasant a land as Canaan, showed so great
depravity, surely it would be an evidence of a corruption no less astonishing, to be inclined
to abuse the blessings of Eden, and the garden of God.
2. If death be brought on mankind only as a benefit, and in that manner which Dr. T.
mentions,—to mortify or moderate their carnal appetites and affections, wean them from
the world, excite them to sober reflections, and lead them to the fear and obedience of God,
&c.—is it not strange that it should fall so heavily on infants, who are not capable of making
any such improvement of it; so that many more of mankind suffer death in infancy, than
in any other equal part of the age of man? Our author sometimes hints, that the death of
infants may be for the correction and punishment of parents. But hath God any need of
such methods to add to parents’ afflictions? Are there not other ways for increasing their
trouble, without destroying the lives of such multitudes of those who are perfectly innocent,
and who, on the supposition, have in no respect any sin belonging to them? On whom death
comes at an age, when not only the subjects are not capable of reflection, or making any
improvement of it, either in suffering, or the expectation of it: but also at an age, when
parents and friends—who alone can improve, and whom Dr. T. supposes alone to be pun-
ished by it—suffer least by being bereaved of them; though the infants themselves sometimes
suffer to great extremity?
3. To suppose, as Dr. T. does, that death is brought on mankind in consequence of
Adam’s sin, not at all as a calamity but only as a favour and benefit, is contrary to the gospel;
which teaches, that when Christ, as the second Adam, comes to remove and destroy that
death, which came by the first Adam, he finds it not as a friend, but an enemy. 1 Cor. xv.
22. “For as in Adam all die, so in Christ shall all be made alive” (with 1 Cor. xv. 25, 26.) “For
he must reign, till he hath put all enemies under his feet. The last enemy that shall be des-
troyed, is death.”
Dr. T. urges, that the afflictions to which mankind are subjected, and particularly their
common mortality, are represented in Scripture as the chastisements of our heavenly Father;
and therefore are designed for our spiritual good, and consequently are not of the nature
of punishments. (So in p. 68, 69. 38, 39. S.)
Though I think the thing asserted far from being true, viz. that the Scripture represents
the afflictions of mankind in general, and particularly their common mortality, as the
chastisement of a heavenly Father; yet it is needless to stand to dispute that matter. For if it
be so, it will be no argument that the afflictions and death of mankind are not evidences of
1012
CHAPTER II. Arguments from universal Mortality.