Rufinus’s
Epilogue to Pamphilus the Martyr’s Apology for Origen
otherwise
The Book Concerning the
Adulteration of the Works of Origen.
————————————
Addressed to Macarius at Pinetum
a.d.
397.
————————————
The next work was sent out at
the same time with Pamphilus’ Apology. Rufinus believed that
Origen’s works had been adulterated by heretics so as to turn his
assertions into support of their own opinions. He therefore, in his
translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, altered
many things which had a heterodox meaning as found in the ordinary
mss.
of Origen, so as to make the work
consistent with itself and with the orthodox views expressed in other
parts of Origen’s writings. How far this process was legitimate
or honest must be judged from a perusal of the controversy which
followed; but it should be borne in mind, first, that the standard of
literary exactness and conscientiousness was not the same in those days
as in ours; secondly, that when everything depended on copyists there
was room for infinite variations in the copies, whether through
negligence, ignorance or fraud; thirdly, that the principles adopted by
Rufinus were precisely those acknowledged by his great opponent Jerome,
in his Treatise De Optimo Genere Interpretandi, and his Letter to
Vigilantius (Letters lxvi and lxi).
My object in the translation
from Greek into Latin of the holy martyr Pamphilus’ Apology for
Origen, which I have given in the preceding volume according to my
ability and the requirements of the matter, is this: I wish you to know
through full information that the rule of faith which has been set
forth above in his writings is that which we
must embrace and hold; for it
is clearly shown that the Catholic opinion is contained in them all.
Nevertheless you have to allow that there are found in his books
certain things not only different from this but in certain cases even
repugnant to it; things which our canons of truth do not sanction, and
which we can neither receive nor approve. As to the cause of this an
opinion has reached me which has been widely entertained, and which I
wish to be fully known by you and by those who desire to know what is
true, since it is possible also that some who have before been actuated
by the love of fault-finding may acquiesce in the truth and reason of
the matter when they have it set before them; for some seem determined
to believe anything in the world to be true rather than that which
withdraws from them the occasions of fault-finding. It must, I think,
be felt to be wholly impossible that a man so learned and so wise, a
man whom even his accusers may well admit to have been neither foolish
nor insane, should have written what is contrary and repugnant to
himself and his own opinions. But even suppose that this could in some
way have happened; suppose, as some perhaps have said, that in the
decline of life he might have forgotten what he had written in his
early days, and have made assertions at variance with his former
opinions; how are we to deal with the fact that we sometimes find in
the very same passages, and, as I may say, almost in successive
sentences, clauses inserted expressive of contrary opinions? Can we
believe that in the same work and in the same book, and even sometimes,
as I have said, in the following paragraph, a man could have forgotten
his own views? For example that, when he had said just before that no
passage in all the Scripture could be found in which the Holy Spirit
was spoken of as made or created, he could have immediately added that
the Holy Spirit had been made along with the rest of the creatures? or
again, that the same man who clearly states that the Father and the Son
are of one substance, or as it is called in Greek Homoousion, could in
the next sentence say that He was of another substance, and was a
created being, when he had but a little before described him as born of
the very nature of God the Father? Or again in the matter of the
resurrection of the flesh, could he who so clearly declared that it was
the nature of the flesh which ascended with the Word of God into
heaven, and there appeared to the celestial Powers, presenting a new
image of himself for them to worship, could he, I ask you, possibly
turn round and say that this flesh was not to be saved? Such things
could not happen even in the case of a man who had taken leave of his
senses and was not sound in the brain. How, therefore, this came to
pass, I will point out with all possible brevity. The heretics are
capable of any violence, they have no remorse and no scruples: this we
are forced to recognize by the audacities of which they have been
frequently convicted. And, just as their father the devil has from the
beginning made it his object to falsify the words of God and twist them
from their true meaning, and subtilely to interpolate among them his
own poisonous ideas, so he has left these successors of his the same
art as their inheritance. Accordingly, when God had said to Adam,
“You shall eat of all the trees of the garden;” he, when he
wished to deceive Eve interpolated a single syllable, by which he
reduced within the narrowest bounds God’s liberality in
permitting all the fruits to be eaten. He said: “Yea, hath God
said, Ye shall not eat of
any
tree of the garden?” and
thus by suggesting the complaint that God’s command was severe,
he more easily persuaded her to transgress the precept. The heretics
have followed the example of their father, the craft of their teacher.
Whenever they found in any of the renowned writers of old days a
discussion of those things which pertain to the glory of God so full
and faithful that every believer could gain profit and instruction from
it, they have not scrupled to infuse into their writings the poisonous
taint of their own false doctrines; this they have done, either by
inserting things which the writers had not said or by changing by
interpolation what they had said, so that their own poisonous heresy
might more easily be asserted and authorized by passing under the name
of all the church writers of the greatest learning and renown; they
meant it to appear that well-known and orthodox men had held as they
did. We hold the clearest proofs of this in the case of the Greek
writers and this adulteration of books is to be found in the case of
many of the ancients; but it will suffice to adduce the testimony of a
few, so that it may be more easily understood what has befallen the
writings of Origen.
Clement, the disciple of the
Apostles, who was bishop of the Roman church next to the Apostles, was
a martyr, wrote the work which is called in the Greek
᾽Αναγνωρισμός
, or in Latin, The Recognition.
2788
In these books
he sets forth again and again
in the name of the Apostle Peter a doctrine which appears to be truly
apostolical: yet in certain passages the heresy of Eunomius is so
brought in that you would imagine that you were listening to an
argument of Eunomius himself, asserting that the Son of God was created
out of no existing elements. Then again that other method of
falsification is introduced, by which it is made to appear that the
nature of the devil and of other demons has not resulted from the
wickedness of their will and purpose, but from an exceptional and
separate quality of their creation, although he in all other places had
taught that every reasonable creature was endowed with the faculty of
free will. There are also some other things inserted into his books
which the church’s creed does not admit. I ask, then, what we are
to think of these things? Are we to believe that an apostolic man, nay,
almost an apostle (since he writes the things which the apostles
speak), one to whom the apostle Paul bore his testimony in the words,
“With Clement and others, my fellow labourers, whose names are in
the book of life” was the writer of words which contradict the
book of life? or are we to say, as we have said before, that perverse
men, in order to gain authority for their own heresies by the use of
the names of holy men, and so procure their readier acceptance,
interpolated these things which it is impossible to believe that the
true authors either thought or wrote?
Again, the other Clement, the
presbyter of Alexandria, and the teacher of that church, in almost all
his books describes the three Persons as having one and the same glory
and eternity: and yet we sometimes find in his books passages in which
he speaks of the Son as a creature of God. Is it credible that so great
a man as he, so orthodox in all points, and so learned, either held
opinions mutually contradictory, or left in writing views concerning
God which it is an impiety, I will not say to believe, but even to
listen to?
Once more, Dionysius the Bishop
of Alexandria, was a most learned maintainer of the church’s
faith, and in passages without end defended the unity and eternity of
the Trinity, so earnestly that some persons of less insight imagine
that he held the views of Sabellius; yet in the books which he wrote
against the heresy of Sabellius, there are things inserted of such a
character that the Arians endeavour to shield themselves under his
authority, and on this account the holy Bishop Athanasius felt himself
compelled to write an apology for his work, because he was assured that
he could not have held strange opinions or have written things in which
he contradicted himself, but felt sure that these things had been
interpreted by ill disposed men.
This opinion we have been led to
form by the force of the facts themselves, in the case of these very
reverend men and doctors of the church; we have found it impossible, I
say, to believe that those reverend men who again and again have
supported the church’s belief should in particular points have
held opinions contradictory to themselves. As to Origen, however, in
whom, as I have said above, are to be found, as in those others,
certain diversities of statement, it will not be sufficient to think
precisely as we think or feel about those who enjoy an established
reputation for orthodoxy; nor could a similar charge be met by a
similar excuse, were it not that its validity is shown by words and
writings of his own in which he makes this fact the subject of earnest
complaint. What he had to suffer while still living in the flesh, while
still having feeling and sight, from the corruption of his books and
treatises, or from counterfeit versions of them, we may learn clearly
from his own letter which he wrote to certain intimate friends at
Alexandria; and by this you will see how it comes to pass that some
things which are self-contradictory are found in his writings.
2789
“Some of those persons who
take a pleasure in accusing their neighbours, bring against us and our
teaching the charge of blasphemy, though from us they have never heard
anything of the kind. Let them take heed to themselves how they refuse
to mark that solemn injunction which says that
2790
‘Revilers shall not inherit the kingdom of God,’ when they
declare that I hold that the father of wickedness and perdition, and of
those who are cast forth from the kingdom of God, that is the devil, is
to be saved, a thing which no man can say even if he has taken leave of
his senses and is manifestly insane. Yet it is no wonder, I think, if
my teaching is falsified by my adversaries, and is corrupted and
adulterated in the same manner as the epistle of Paul the Apostle.
Certain men, as we know, compiled a false epistle under the name of
Paul, so that they might trouble the Thessalonians as if the day of the
Lord were nigh at hand, and thus
beguile them. It is on account
of that false epistle that he wrote these words in the second epistle
to the Thessalonians:
2791
‘We
beseech you, brethren, by the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our
gathering together unto him; to the end that ye be not quickly shaken
from your mind, nor yet be troubled, either by spirit or by word or by
letter as sent from us, as that the day of the Lord is at hand. Let no
man beguile you in any wise.’ It is something of the same kind, I
perceive, which is happening to us also. A certain promoter of heresy,
after a discussion which had been held between us in the presence of
many persons, and notes of it had been taken, procured the document
from those who had written out the notes, and added or struck out
whatever he chose, and changed things as he thought right, and
published it abroad as if it were my work, but pointing in triumphant
scorn at the expressions which he had himself inserted. The brethren in
Palestine, indignant at this, sent a man to me at Athens to obtain from
me an authentic copy of the work. Up to that time I had never even read
it over again or revised it: it had been so completely neglected and
thrown aside that it could hardly be found. Nevertheless, I sent it:
and,—God is witness that I am speaking the truth,—when I
met the man himself who had adulterated the work, and took him to task
for having done so, he answered, as if he were giving me satisfaction:
“I did it because I wished to improve that treatise and to purge
away its faults.” What kind of a purging was this that he applied
to my dissertation? such a purging as Marcion or his successor Apelles
after him gave to the Gospels and to the writings of the Apostle. They
subverted the true text of Scripture; and this man similarly first took
away the true statements which I had made, and then inserted what was
false to furnish grounds for accusation against me. But, though those
who have dared to do this are impious and heretical men, yet those who
give credence to such accusations against us shall not escape the
judgment of God. There are others also, not a few, who have done this
through a wish to throw confusion into the churches. Lately, a certain
heretic who had seen me at Ephesus and had refused to meet me, and had
not opened his mouth in my presence, but for some reason or other had
avoided doing so, afterwards composed a dissertation according to his
own fancy, partly mine, partly his own, and sent it to his disciples in
various places: I know that it reached those who were in Rome, and I
doubt not that it reached others also. He was behaving in the same
reckless way at Antioch also before I came there: and the dissertation
which he brought with him came into the hands of many of our friends.
But when I arrived, I took him to task in the presence of many persons,
and, when he persisted, with a complete absence of shame, in the
impudent defence of his forgery, I demanded that the book should be
brought in amongst us, so that my mode of speech might be recognized by
the brethren, who of course knew the points on which I am accustomed to
insist and the method of teaching which I employ. He did not, however,
venture to bring in the book, and his assertions were refuted by them
all and he himself was convicted of forgery, and thus the brethren were
taught a lesson not to give ear to such accusations. If then any one is
willing to trust me at all—I speak as in the sight of
God—let him believe what I say about the things which are falsely
inserted in my letter. But if any man refuses to believe me, and
chooses to speak evil of me, it is not to me that he does the injury:
he will himself be arraigned as a false witness before God, since he is
either bearing false witness against his neighbour, or giving credit to
those who bear it.”
Such are the complaints which he
made while still living, and while he was still able to detect the
corruptions and falsifications which had been made in his books. There
is another letter of his, in which I remember to have read a complaint
of the falsifying of his writings; but I have not a copy of it at hand,
otherwise I could add to those which I have quoted a second testimony
in favour of his good faith and veracity direct from himself. But I
think that I have said enough to satisfy those who listen to what is
said, not in the interest of strife and detraction, but in that of a
love of truth. I have shown and proved in the case of the saintly men
of whom I have made mention, and of whose orthodoxy is no question,
that, where the tenor of a book is presumably right, anything which is
found in it contrary to the faith of the church is more properly
believed to have been inserted by heretics than to have been written by
the author: and I cannot think it an absurd demand that the same thing
should be believed in the case of Origen, not only because the argument
is similar but because of the witness given by himself in the
complaints which I have brought out from his writings: otherwise we
must believe that, like a silly or insane per
son, he has written in
contradiction to himself.
As to the possibility that the
heretics may have acted in the violent manner supposed, such wickedness
may easily be believed of them. They have given a specimen of it, which
makes it credible in the present case, in the fact that they have been
unable to keep off their impious hands even from the sacred words of
the Gospel. Any one who has a mind to see how they have acted in the
case of the Acts of the Apostles or their Epistles, how they have
befouled them and gnawed them away, how they have defiled them in every
kind of way, sometimes adding words which expressed their impious
doctrine, sometimes taking out the opposing truths, will understand it
most fully if he will read the books of Tertullian written against
Marcion. It is no great thing that they should have corrupted the
writings of Origen when they have dared to corrupt the sayings of God
our Saviour. It is true that some persons may withhold their assent
from what I am saying on the ground of the difference of the heresies;
since it was one kind of heresy the partisans of which corrupted the
Gospels, but it is another which is aimed at in these passages which,
as we assert, have been inserted in the works of Origen. Let those who
have such doubts consider that, as in all the saints dwells the one
spirit of God (for the Apostle says,
2792
“The spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophets,”
and again,
2793
“We all have been made to
drink of that one spirit”); so also in all the heretics dwells
the one spirit of the devil, who teaches them all and at all times the
same or similar wickedness.
There may, however, be some to
whom the instances we have given have less persuasive force because
they have to do with Greek writers; and therefore, although it is a
Greek writer for whom I am pleading, yet, since it is the Latin tongue
which is, so to speak, entrusted with the argument, and they are Latin
people before whom you have earnestly begged me to plead the cause of
these men, and to show what wounds they suffer by the calumnious
renderings of their works, it will be satisfactory to show that things
of the same kind have happened to Latin as well as Greek writers, and
that men approved for their saintly character have had a storm of
calumny raised against them by the falsification of their works. I will
recount things of still recent memory, so that nothing may be lacking
to the manifest credibility of my contention, and its truth may lie
open for all to see.
Hilary Bishop of Pictavium
2794
was a believer in the Catholic
doctrine, and wrote a very complete work of instruction with the view
of bringing back from their error those who had subscribed the
faithless creed of Ariminum.
2795
This book fell
into the hands of his adversaries and ill wishers, whether, as some
said, by bribing his secretary, or by no matter what other cause. He
knew nothing of this: but the book was so falsified by them, the
saintly man being all the while entirely unconscious of it, that, when
his enemies began to accuse him of heresy in the episcopal assembly, as
holding what they knew they had corruptly inserted in his manuscript,
he himself demanded the production of his book as evidence of his
faith. It was brought from his house, and was found to be full of
matter which he repudiated: but it caused him to be excommunicated and
to be excluded from the meeting of the synod. In this case, however,
though the crime was one of unexampled wickedness, the man who was the
victim of it was alive, and present in the flesh; and the hostile
faction could be convicted and brought to punishment, when their tricks
became known and their machinations were exposed. A remedy was applied
through statements, explanations, and similar things: for living men
can take action on their own behalf, the dead can refute no accusations
under which they labour.
Take another case. The whole
collection of the letters of the martyr Cyprian is usually found in a
single manuscript. Into this collection certain heretics who held a
blasphemous doctrine about the Holy Spirit inserted a treatise of
Tertullian on the Trinity, which was faultily expressed though he is
himself an upholder of our faith: and from the copies thus made they
wrote out a number of others; these they distributed through the whole
of the vast city of Constantinople at a very low price: men were
attracted by this cheapness and readily bought up the documents full of
hidden snares of which they knew nothing; and thus the heretics found
means of gaining credit for their impious doctrines through the
authority of a great name. It happened,
however, that, shortly after
the publication, there were found there some of our catholic brothers
who were able to expose this wicked fabrication, and recalled as many
as they could reach from the entanglements of error. In this they
partly succeeded. But there were a great many in those parts who
remained convinced that the saintly martyr Cyprian held the belief
which had been erroneously expressed by Tertullian.
I will add one other instance of
the falsification of a document. It is one of recent memory, though it
is an example of the primeval subtlety, and it surpasses all the
stories of the ancients.
Bishop Damasus, at the time when
a consultation was held in the matter of the reconciling of the
followers of Apollinarius to the church,
2796
desired to have a document setting
forth the faith of the church, which should be subscribed by those who
wished to be reconciled. The compiling of this document he entrusted to
a certain friend of his, a presbyter and a highly accomplished man,
2797
who usually acted for him in matters
of this kind. When he came to compose the document, he found it
necessary, in speaking of the Incarnation of our Lord, to apply to him
the expression “Homo Dominicus.” The Apollinarists
2798
took offence at this expression, and
began to impugn it as a novelty. The writer of the document thereupon
undertook to defend himself, and to confute the objectors by the
authority of ancient Catholic writers; and he happened to show to one
of those who complained of the novelty of the expression a book of the
bishop Athanasius in which the word which was under discussion
occurred. The man to whom this evidence was offered appeared to be
convinced, and asked that the manuscript should be lent to him so that
he might convince the rest who from their ignorance were still
maintaining their objections. When he had got the manuscript into his
hands he devised a perfectly new method of falsification. He first
erased the passage in which the expression occurred, and then wrote in
again the same words which he had erased. He returned the paper, and it
was accepted without question. The controversy about this expression
again arose; the manuscript was brought forward: the expression in
question was found in it, but in a position where there had been an
erasure: and the man who had brought forward such a manuscript lost all
authority, since the erasure seemed to be the proof of malpractice and
falsification. However, in this case as in one which I mentioned
before, it was a living man who was thus treated by a living man, and
he at once did all in his power to lay bare the iniquitous fraud which
had been committed, and to remove the stain of this nefarious act from
the man who was innocent and had done no evil of the kind, and to
attach it to the real author of the deed, so that it should completely
overwhelm him with infamy.
Since, then, Origen in his
letter complains with his own voice that he has suffered such things at
the hands of the heretics who wished him ill, and similar things have
happened in the case of many other orthodox men among both the dead and
the living, and since in the cases adduced, men’s writings are
proved to have been tampered with in a similar way: what determined
obstinacy is this, which refuses to admit the same excuse when the case
is the same, and, when the circumstances are parallel, assigns to one
party the allowance due to respect, but to another infamy due to a
criminal. The truth must be told, and must not lie hid at this point;
for it is impossible for any man really to judge so unjustly as to form
different opinions on cases which are similar. The fact is that the
prompters of Origen’s accusers are men who make long
controversial discourses in the churches,
2799
and even write books the whole matter
of which is borrowed from him, and who wish to deter men of simple mind
from reading him, for fear that their plagiarisms should become widely
known, though, indeed, their appropriations would be no reproach to
them if they were not ungrateful to their master.
For instance, one of these
men,
2800
who thinks that a necessity is laid upon
him,
2801
like that of preaching the Gospel, to
speak evil of Origen among all nations and tongues, declared in a vast
assembly of Christian hearers that he had read six thousand of his
works. Surely, if his object in reading these were, as he is in the
habit of asserting, only to acquaint himself with Origen’s
faults, ten or twenty or at most thirty of these works would have
sufficed for the purpose.
But to read six thousand books
is no longer wishing to know the man, but giving up almost one’s
whole life to his teaching and researches. On what ground then can his
words be worthy of credit when he blames men who have only read quite a
few of these books while their rule of faith is kept sacred and their
piety unimpaired.
What has been said may suffice
to show what opinion we ought to form of the books of Origen. I think
that every one who has at heart the interests of truth, not of
controversy, may easily assent to the well-proved statements I have
made. But if any man perseveres in his contentiousness, we have no such
custom.
2802
It is a settled custom among us,
when we read him, to hold fast that which is good, according to the
apostolic injunction. If we find in these books anything discrepant to
the Catholic faith, we suspect that it has been inserted by the
heretics, and consider it as alien from his opinion as it is from our
faith. If, however, this is a mistake of ours, we run, as I think, no
danger from such an error; for we ourselves, through God’s help,
continue unharmed by avoiding what we hold in suspicion and condemn:
and further we shall not be accounted accusers of our brethren before
God (you will remember that the accusing of the brethren is the special
work of the devil, and that he received the name of devil
2803
from his being a slanderer). Moreover,
we thus escape the sentence pronounced on evil speakers, which
separates those who are such from the kingdom of God.
2788
Rufinus was deceived as was the whole world until the revival of
learning, in believing this fabrication to be the work of Clement. It
is really a romance in the form of an autobiography of Clement,
supposed to be addressed to James of Jerusalem; and was written
probably in Asia Minor or Syria about
a.d.
200. See Article “Clementine Literature” in Dict. of Ch.
Biog.
2789
The letter is headed “On the adulteration and corruption of
his books; from the 4th book of the letters of Origen: a letter written
to certain familiar friends at Alexandria.”
2790
1 Cor. vi. 10
2791
2 Thess. ii.
1–3
2792
1 Cor. xiv.
32
2793
1 Cor. xii.
13
2794
Poictiers.
2795
There seem to be no means of throwing light upon this story.
Hilary was not at the council of Ariminum, but at that of Seleucia,
held the same year (359). On his return to Gaul in 361 he endeavoured,
in various meetings of bishops to reunite with the Homoousians those
who had subscribed the creed of Ariminum. (See Art. on Hilary Pictav.
in Dict. of Christ. Biography.) It may have been in one of these
meetings that this scene occurred.
2796
This was in 382, the year after the Council of Constantinople.
Jerome had come from Constantinople to Rome with the Eastern Bishops
Epiphanius of Salamis in Cyprus and Paulinus of Antioch. His position
at Rome is described in the words of his letter (cxxiii) to Ageruchia,
c. 10. “I was assisting Damasus in matters of ecclesiastical
literature, and answering the questions discussed in the Councils of
the East and the West.”
2797
Jerome.
2798
Apollinaris, in his reaction from Arianism, held that the Godhead
supplied the place of the human soul in Christ. Hence their objection
to this expression.
2799
This is believed to refer to Epiphanius, whose anti-Origenistic
sermon at Jerusalem in the year 394 greatly irritated the Bishops John
and Rufinus. See Jerome Ep. li, and
“Against John of
Jerusalem,”
c. 14.
2800
Epiphanius.
2801
1 Cor. ix. 16
2802
Adapted from
1 Cor. xi. 16
2803
Διάβολος
(diabolus)
from
διαβάλλω
to slander.