On Bk. VI.
chap. 8, § 5 (note 4).
Origen and Demetrius
.
The friendship of Demetrius for
Origen began early and continued, apparently without interruption, for
many years. In 203 he committed to him the charge of the catechetical
school (chap. 3); in the present chapter we find him encouraging him
after learning of his rash deed; some years afterward, upon
Origen’s return from a visit to Rome, where his fame as a teacher
had already become very great, Demetrius still showed the very best
spirit toward him (chap. 14); and a little later sent him into Arabia
to give instruction to an officer in that country (chap. 19). It is
soon after this that the first sign of a difference between the two men
appears, upon the occasion of Origen’s preaching in Cæsarea
(
ibid
.). There seems, however, to have been no lasting quarrel,
if there was any quarrel at all; for in 231 we find Demetrius giving
Origen letters of recommendation upon the occasion of his visit to
Achaia (see below, p. 396). The fact that he gives him these letters,
thus recognizing him as a member of his church in good standing, and
sending him upon his important mission with his official approval,
shows that no open break between himself and Origen can as yet have
taken place. But in his commentary on John (Tom. VI.
præf
.)
Origen shows us that his last years in Alexandria were by no means
pleasant ones. He compares his troubles there to the waves of a stormy
sea, and his final departure to the exodus of the children of Israel.
We know that he had been engaged for some time in writing commentaries,
and that the first five books of his commentary on
John—epoch-making in their significance, and sure to cause a
sensation in orthodox, conservative circles—had recently
appeared. We know that his reputation for heterodoxy was already quite
widespread and that the majority of the Egyptian clergy were by no
means upon his side. The trials to which he refers, therefore, may well
have been a result of this hostility to his teachings existing among
the clergy about him, and Demetrius may have shared to an extent in the
common feeling. At the same time his disapproval cannot have been very
pronounced, or he could not have given his official sanction to
Origen’s important visit to Achaia. But now, things being in this
condition, Origen set out upon his mission, leaving Heraclas in charge
of his school, and undoubtedly with the expectation of returning again,
for he left the unfinished sixth book of his commentary on John behind
him (see preface to the sixth book). He stopped in Palestine on his way
to Athens, and there was ordained a presbyter by the bishops of that
country (upon the motives which prompted him in the matter, see below,
p. 397). The result was a complete break between Demetrius and himself,
and his condemnation by an Alexandrian synod. To understand
Demetrius’ action in the matter, we must remember that both
Eusebius and Jerome attribute the change in his attitude to jealousy
of
Origen.
They may be too harsh in their judgment, and yet it is certainly not at
all unnatural that the growing power and fame of his young catechumen
should in time affect, all unconsciously, his attitude toward him. But
we must not do Demetrius an injustice. There is no sign that his
jealousy led him to attack Origen, or to seek to undermine his
influence, and we have no right to accuse him, without ground, of such
unchristian conduct. At the same time, while he remained, as he
supposed, an honest friend of Origen’s, the least feeling of
jealousy (and it would have been remarkable had he never felt the
least) would make him more suspicious of the latter’s conduct,
and more prone to notice in his actions anything which might be
interpreted as an infringement of his own prerogatives, or a disregard
of the full respect due him. We seem to see a sign of this
over-sensitiveness (most natural under the circumstances) in his severe
disapproval of Origen’s preaching in Cæsarea, which
surprised the Palestinian bishops, but which is not surprising when we
realize that Demetrius might so easily construe it as a token of
growing disrespect for his authority on the part of his rising young
school principal. It is plain enough, if he was in this state of mind,
that he might in all sincerity have given letters of recommendation to
Origen and have wished him God speed upon his mission, and yet that the
news of his ordination to the presbyterate by foreign bishops, without
his own approval or consent, and indeed in opposition to his own
principles and to ecclesiastical law, should at once arouse his ire,
and, by giving occasion for what seemed righteous indignation, open the
floodgates for all the smothered jealousy of years. In such a temper of
mind he could not do otherwise than listen willingly to all the
accusations of heresy against Origen, which were no doubt busily
circulated in his absence, and it was inevitable that he should believe
it his duty to take decided steps against a man who was a heretic, and
at the same time showed complete disregard of the rules and customs of
the Church, and of the rights of his bishop. The result was the
definitive and final exclusion of Origen from communion with the
Alexandrian church, and his degradation from the office of presbyter by
decree of the Alexandrian synods described above, p. 392 sq. The two
grounds of the sentence passed by these synods were plainly his
irregular ordination to the priesthood when constitutionally unfit for
it (cf. what Eusebius says in this chapter), and his heterodoxy (cf.
e.g. the synodical epistle of the Egyptian bishops given in
Mansi’s
Collect. Concil
. IX. col. 524, and also
Jerome’s epistle
ad Pammachium et Oceanum
, § 10, and
Rufinus’
Apologi in Hieron
. II. 21). That the ordination
to the priesthood of one who had mutilated himself was not universally
considered uncanonical in the time of Origen is proved by the fact that
the Palestinian bishops (whom Origen cannot have allowed to remain
ignorant of his condition) all united in ordaining him. But the very
fact that they all united (which has perplexed some scholars) leads us
to think that they realized that their action was somewhat irregular,
and hence wished to give it sanction by the participation of a number
of bishops. The first canon of the Council of Nicæa forbids such
ordination, and the canon is doubtless but the repetition of an older
one (cf.
Apost. Canons
, 21 to 24, and see Hefele,
Conciliengesch
. I. p. 377), and yet Origen’s consent to his ordination
makes it improbable that there was in force in his time, even in
Alexandria, a canon placing absolute and unconditional clerical
disabilities upon such as he. That the action, however, was considered
at least irregular in Alexandria, is proved by the position taken in
the matter by Demetrius; and the fact that he made so much of it leads
us to believe that the synod, called by him, may now have made canon
law of what was before only custom, and may have condemned Origen for
violating that custom which they considered as binding as law.
Certainly had there been no such custom, and had it not seemed to
Demetrius absolutely binding, he would have ordained Origen to the
priesthood long before. His ordination in Palestine was in violation of
what was known to be Demetrius’ own principle, and the principle
of the Alexandrian church, even if the principle was not, until this
time or later, formulated into a canon.