imply that even down to that time the cultus of images was not established in the West, a
526
proposition too ridiculous to be defended by anyone. It is indeed worthy of notice that all
the authors cited are Frankish, (1) the Annales Francorum (a.d. 808) in the continuation of
the same (a.d. 814), in an anonymous life of Charlemagne, and the Annales written after
819; (2) Eginhard in his Annales Francorum (a.d. 829); (3) the Gallican bishops at Paris,
824;512 (4) Hincmar of Rheims; (5) Ado, bishop of Vienne (died 875); (6) Anastasius ac-
knowledges that the French had not accepted the veneration of the sacred images; (7) The
Chronicle of St. Bertinus (after 884); (8) The Annales Francorum after the council still speak
of it as pseudo; (9) Regino, Abbot of Prum (circa 910); (10) the Chronicle of St. Bertinus, of
the Xth Century. (11) Hermanus Contractus: (12) the author who continued the Gestes
Francorum to a.d. 1165; (13) Roger Hoverden (a.d. 1204); (14) Conrade à Lichtenau, Abbot
of Urspurg (circa 1230); (15) Matthew of Westminster.
No doubt to these, given in Palmer, who has made much use of Lannoy, others could
be added; but they are enough to shew that the council was very little known, and that none
of these writers had ever seen its acts.
Sir William is of opinion that by what precedes in his book he has “proved that for at
least five centuries and a half the Council of Nice remained rejected in the Western Church.”
I venture to think that the most he has proved is that during that period of time he has been
able to find fifteen individuals who for one reason or another wrote rejecting that council,
that is to say three in a century, a number which does not seem quite sufficient to make the
foundation of so considerable a generalization as “the Western Church.” The further con-
clusion of Sir William, I think, every scholar will reject as simply preposterous, viz.: “In fact
the doctrine of the adoration of images [by which he means the doctrine taught by the II.
Council of Nice] was never received in the West, except where the influence of the Roman
See was predominant” (p. 211).
Sir William is always, however, honest, and the following quotation which he himself
makes from Cardinal Bellarmine may well go far toward explaining the erroneous or imper-
fect statements he has so learnedly and laboriously gathered together. “Bellarmine says: ‘It
is very credible that St. Thomas, Alexander of Hales, and other scholastic doctors had not
seen the second synod of Nice, nor the eighth general synod;’ he adds that they ‘were long
in obscurity, and were first published in our own age, as may be known from their not being
extant in the older volumes of the councils; and St. Thomas and the other ancient schoolmen
never make any mention of this Nicene Synod.’ (Bell. De Imag. Sanct. Lib. II. cap. xxij.)”
2. What the Council decreed.
The council decreed that similar veneration and honour should be paid to the repres-
entations of the Lord and of the Saints as was accustomed to be paid to the “laurata” and
512 The true date is 825.
988
Introduction.