Chapter XVI.—The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.1568
1568 Montanism must not be looked upon as a heresy in the ordinary sense of the term. The movement lay
in the sphere of life and discipline rather than in that of theology. Its fundamental proposition was the continuance
of divine revelation which was begun under the old Dispensation, was carried on in the time of Christ and his
apostles, and reached its highest development under the dispensation of the Paraclete, which opened with the
activity of Montanus. This Montanus was a Phrygian, who, in the latter part of the second century, began to fall
into states of ecstasy and to have visions, and believed himself a divinely inspired prophet, through whom the
promised Paraclete spoke, and with whom therefore the dispensation of that Paraclete began. Two noble ladies
(Priscilla and Maximilla) attached themselves to Montanus, and had visions and prophesied in the same way.
These constituted the three original prophets of the sect, and all that they taught was claimed to be of binding
authority on all. They were quite orthodox, accepted fully the doctrinal teachings of the Catholic Church, and
did not pretend to alter in any way the revelation given by Christ and his apostles. But they claimed that some
things had not been revealed by them, because at that early stage the Church was not able to bear them; but that
such additional revelations were now given, because the fullness of time had come which was to precede the
second coming of Christ. These revelations had to do not at all with theology, but wholly with matters of life
and discipline. They taught a rigid asceticism over against the growing worldliness of the Church, severe discipline
over against its laxer methods, and finally the universal priesthood of believers (even female), and their right to
perform all the functions of church officers, over against the growing sacerdotalism of the Church. They were
thus in a sense reformers, or perhaps reactionaries is a better term, who wished to bring back, or to preserve
against corruption, the original principles and methods of the Church. They aimed at a puritanic reaction against
worldliness, and of a democratic reaction against growing aristocracy in the Church. They insisted that ministers
were made by God alone, by the direct endowment of his Spirit in distinction from human ordination. They
looked upon their prophets—supernaturally called and endowed by the Spirit—as supreme in the Church. They
claimed that all gross offenders should be excommunicated, and that neither they nor the lax should ever be re-
admitted to the Church. They encouraged celibacy, increased the number and severity of fasts, eschewed worldly
amusements, &c. This rigid asceticism was enjoined by the revelation of the Spirit through their prophets, and
was promoted by their belief in the speedy coming of Christ to set up his kingdom on earth, which was likewise
prophesied. They were thus pre-Millenarians or Chiliasts. The movement spread rapidly in Asia Minor and in
North Africa, and for a time in Rome itself. It appealed very powerfully to the sterner moralists, stricter discip-
linarians, and more deeply pious minds among the Christians. All the puritanically inclined schisms of this
period attracted many of the better class of Christians, and this one had the additional advantage of claiming
the authority of divine revelation for its strict principles. The greatest convert was Tertullian, who, in 201 or
202, attracted by the asceticism and disciplinary rigor of the sect, attached himself to it, and remained until his
death its most powerful advocate. He seems to have stood at the head of a separatist congregation of Montanists
in Carthage, and yet never to have been excommunicated by the Catholic Church. Montanism made so much
stir in Asia Minor that synods were called before the end of the second century to consider the matter, and finally,
though not without hesitation, the whole movement was officially condemned. Later, the condemnation was
ratified in Rome and also in North Africa, and Montanism gradually degenerated, and finally, after two or three
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.
542
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.