lieved in such a charge against the cognitor? Since the acts of the Collation are so voluminous
we present herewith a digest. The meeting, the election of disputants and scribes, the matter
of the subscriptions, are then recapitulated. In the attempt at discussion, the whole aim of
the Donatist disputants was to avoid coming to the point to be debated, while the Catholic
representatives exerted themselves to reach just that goal and nothing else. When at last
the Donatists were forced to the issue, they were vanquished by the clear testimony of the
Scriptures to the universality of the Church. Any one separated from this unity has not life;
the wrath of God abides upon him. The communion with the wicked does not defile any
one by the mere participation in the sacraments, but only by agreement with their deeds.
All these truths they had to acknowledge. The Catholics had prevented a confusion between
the doctrinal and historical sides of the question. In the discussion of the documents, the
chief offset to all the points was found in the case of the Maximianists, although the
397
Donatists plead that a case should not be prejudged by a case, nor a person by a person. All
the accusations which had been concentrated against Cæcilian they were unable to meet
with proofs. Defeated men are wont to suggest such a defense as the corruption of the judge.
Then says the paper in effect: If you will believe us, let us hold fast to the unity which God
commands and loves. But if you are unwilling to believe us, read the proceedings themselves,
or allow them to be read to you, and do you yourselves test whether what we have written
to you be true. If you decline all these, and will still cleave to the Donatists, we are clear
from your judgment. If you will renounce the schism, we will welcome you to the peace of
Christ, and you will have the profit of that sacrament which was administered among you
to judgment.
The Donatist presbyters Saturninus and Eufrates had joined the Catholic Church and
maintained their rank. Augustin writes [Ep. cxlii.], c. 412 A.D., to express his joy at their
arrival and bids them not to grieve at his absence, for they are now in the one Church whose
note of universality he expands as the one Body of the one Head, and as the one house in
all the earth; in the unity of this house we rejoice as embracive of those transmarine churches,
to whom the appeal had vainly been made by the Donatists. He who lives evilly in this
Church eats and drinks condemnation to himself, but whoever lives correctly, another case
and another person cannot prejudge him. The Donatists had protested against the parallel
proofs drawn from the Maximianists, on the ground that a case should not be prejudged
by a case nor a person by a person. On the Lord’s threshing-floor the chaff must be tolerated.
He exhorts them to a faithful discharge of their clerical duties, especially in mercifulness
and also in prayer for the removal of the schism.
The hostility of the Donatists was increased by the Collation. Their clergy charged the
judge with bribery, and protested against the unfairness of the trial, the compulsion of the
meeting, the unjust decision. Augustin felt compelled to write, c. 412 A.D., to the people
in order to stay the fury of their leaders. The treatise is known as Ad Donatistas post Col-
679
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.