Elucidations.
I.
(Purpose of the
Stromata
2143
)
The
Alexandrian Gnostics were the pestilent
outgrowth of
pseudo-Platonism;
and nobody could comprehend
their root-errors, and their branching thorns and thistles, better
than Clement. His superiority in philosophy and classical culture was
exhibited, therefore, in his writings, as a necessary preliminary. Like a
good nautical combatant, his effort was to “get to windward,”
and so bear down upon the enemy (to use an anachronism) with heavy-shotted
broadsides. And we must not blame Clement for his plan of “taking
the wind out of their sails,” by showing that an eclectic philosophy
might be made to harmonize with the Gospel. His plan was that of melting
the gold out of divers ores, and throwing the dross away. Pure gold,
he argues, is gold wherever it may be found, and even in the purse of
“thieves and robbers.” So, then, he “takes from them
the armour in which they trusted, and divides the spoils.” He
will not concede to them the name of “Gnostics,” but wrests
it from them, just as we reclaim the name of “Catholics”
from the Tridentine innovators, who have imposed a modern creed (and
are constantly adding to it) upon the Latin churches. Here, then,
let me quote the
Account
of Bishop Kaye. He says, “The
object of Clement, in composing the
Stromata
, was to describe the
true ‘Gnostic,’ or perfect Christian, in order to furnish
the believer with a model for his imitation, and to prevent him from
being led astray by the representations of the Valentinians and other
gnostic sects.” … “Before we proceed to consider
his description of the Gnostic, however, it will be necessary briefly to
review his opinions respecting the nature and condition of man.”
Here follows a luminous analysis (occupying pp.
229–238 of Kaye’s work), after which he says,—
“The foregoing brief notice of
Clement’s opinions respecting man, his soul, and his fallen
state, appeared necessary as an introduction to the description
of the
true Gnostic
. By
γνῶσις
,
Clement understood the perfect knowledge of all that
relates to God, His nature, and dispensations. He speaks of
a twofold knowledge,—one, common to all men, and born
of sense; the other, the genuine
γνῶσις
,
bred from the intellect, the mind, and its reason. This latter is not
born with men, but must be gained and by practice formed into a habit.
The initiated
find its perfection in a loving mysticism, which
this never-failing love makes lasting.”
So, further, this learned analyst, not blindly,
but always with scientific conscience and judicial impartiality,
expounds his author; and, without some such guide, I despair of
securing the real interest of the youthful student. Butler’s
Analogy
and Aristotle’s
Ethics
are always analyzed
for learners, by editors of their works; and hence I have ventured to
direct attention to this “guide, philosopher, and friend”
of my own inquiries.
2144
II.
(Pantænus and His School.
2145
)
The catechetical school at
Alexandria was already ancient; for Eusebius describes it as
ἐξ
ἀρχαίου
ἔθους
and St. Jerome dates its
origin from the first planting of Christianity. Many things conspired
to make this city the very head of Catholic Christendom, at this time;
for the whole
East centred here, and the East was Christendom while
the West was yet a missionary field almost entirely. Demetrius, then
bishop, at the times with which we are now concerned, sent Pantænus
to convert the Hindoos, and, whatever his success or failure there,
he brought back reports that Christians were there before him, the
offspring of St. Bartholomew’s preaching; and, in proof thereof,
he brought with him a copy of St. Matthew’s Gospel in the
Hebrew tongue
2146
which became one of the treasures of the
church on the Nile.
But it deserves note, that, because of the learning
concentrated in this place, the bishops of Alexandria were, from the
beginning, the great authorities as to the Easter cycle and the annual
computation of Easter, which new created the science of astronomy as
one result. The Council of Nice, in settling the laws for the
observance of the Feast of the Resurrection, extended the function of
the Alexandrian See in this respect; for it was charged with the duty
of giving notice of the day when Easter should fall every year, to all
the churches. And easily might an ambitious primate of Egypt have
imagined himself superior to all other bishops at that time; for, as
Bingham observes,
2147
he was the greatest in the world,
“for the absoluteness of his power, and the extent of his
jurisdiction.” And this greatness of Alexandria was
ancient,
we must remember, at the Nicene epoch; for their
celebrated canon (VI.) reads, “
Let ancient customs
prevail;
so that in Egypt, Lybia, and Pentapolis, the Bishop of
Alexandria shall have power over all these.” Similar powers and
privileges, over their own regions, were recognised in Rome and
Antioch.
III.
(Tradition.
2148
)
The apostles
distinguish between vain traditions of the Jews,
and their own Christian
παραδόσεις
the
tradita apostolica
(
2 Tim. i. 13, 14
;
2 Tim. ii. 2
;
1 Cor. xi.
2
;
2 Thess. iii. 6
;
1 Cor. v. 8
;
1 Cor. xvi. 2
). Among these were (1)
the authentication of their own Scriptures; (2) certain “forms of
sound words,” afterwards digested into liturgies; (3) the rules for
celebrating the Lord’s Supper, and of administering baptism; (4)
the Christian Passover and the weekly Lord’s Day; (5) the Jewish
Sabbath and ordinances, how far to be respected while the temple yet
stood; (6) the kiss of charity, and other observances of public worship;
(7) the
agapæ
, the rules about widows, etc.
In some degree these were the secret of the Church, with
which “strangers intermeddled not” lawfully. The
Lord’s Supper was celebrated after the catechumens and mere
hearers had withdrawn, and nobody was suffered to be present without
receiving the sacrament. But, after the conversion of the empire, the
canons and constitutions universally dispersed made public all
these
tradita;
and the liturgies also were everywhere made
known. It is idle, therefore, to shelter under theories of the
Disciplina Arcani
, those Middle-Age inventions, of which
antiquity shows no trace but in many ways contradicts emphatically;
e.g., the Eucharist, celebrated after the withdrawal of the
non-communicants, and received, in both kinds, by all present, cannot
be pleaded as the “secret” which justifies a ceremony in an
unknown tongue and otherwise utterly different; in which the priest
alone partakes, in which the cup is denied to the laity and which is
exhibited with great pomp before all comers with no general
participation.
IV.
(Esoteric Doctrine.
2149
)
Early Christians, according to Clement,
taught to all alike, (1) all things necessary to salvation, (2) all the
whole Scriptures, and (3) all the apostolic traditions. This is evident
from passages
noted here and hereafter. But, in the presence of the
heathen, they remembered our Lord’s words, and were careful not
“to cast pearls before swine.” Like St. Paul before Felix,
they “reasoned of righteousness, temperance, and judgment to
come,” when dealing with men who knew not God, preaching Christ to
them in a practical way. In their instructions to the churches, they were
able to say with the same apostle, “I am pure from the blood of
all men, for I have not shunned to declare unto you
all the counsel
of God
.” Yet, even in the Church, they fed babes with milk,
and the more intelligent with the meat of God’s word. What that
meat was, we discover in the
Stromata
, when our author defines
the true Gnostic, who follows whithersoever God leads him in
the
divinely inspired Scriptures
. He recognises many who merely taste the
Scriptures as
believers;
but the true Gnostic is a
gnomon
of truth, an index to others of the whole knowledge of Christ.
What we teach children in the Sunday school, and what we
teach young men in the theological seminary, must illustrate the two
ideas; the same truths to babes in element, but to men in all their
bearings and relations.
The defenders of the modern creed of Pius the
Fourth (
a.d.
1564), finding no authority in
Holy Scripture for most of its peculiarities, which are all imposed as
requisite to salvation as if it were the Apostles’ Creed itself,
endeavour to support them, by asserting that they belonged to the
secret teaching of the early Church, of which they claim Clement as a
witness. But the fallacy is obvious. Either they were thus
secreted
, or they were not. If not, as is most evident (because
they contradict what was openly professed), then no ground for the
pretence. But suppose they were, what follows? Such secrets were no
part of the faith, and could not become so at a later period. If they
were kept secret by the new theologians, and taught to
“Gnostics” only, they would still be without primitive
example, but might be less objectionable. But, no! they are imposed
upon all, as if part of the ancient creeds; imposed, as if articles of
the Catholic faith, on the most illiterate peasant, whose mere
doubt
as to any of them excludes him from the Church here, and
from salvation hereafter. Such, then, is a fatal departure from
Catholic orthodoxy and the traditions of the ancients. The whole system
is a novelty, and the product of the most barren and corrupt period of
Occidental history.
The Church, as Clement shows, never made any
secret
of any article of the Christian faith; and, as soon as she
was free from persecution, the whole testimony of the Ante-Nicene
Fathers was summed up in the Nicæno-Constantinopolitan Confession.
This only is the Catholic faith, and the council forbade any additions
thereto, in the way of a symbol. See Professor Shedd’s
Christian Doctrine
, vol. ii. p. 438. Ed. 1864, New York.
V.
(p. 302,
note
9
, Elucidation III., continued.)
This is a valuable
passage for the illustration of our author’s views
of the nature of tradition, (
κατὰ τὸν
σεμνὸν τῆς
παραδόσεως
κανόνα
as a canon “from
the creation of the world;” a tradition preluding the tradition
of true knowledge; a divine mystery preparing for the knowledge of
mysteries,—clearing the ground from thorns and weeds, beforehand,
so that the seed of the Word may not be choked. Now, in this tradition,
he includes a true idea of Gentilism as well as of the Hebrew Church and
its covenant relations; in short, whatever a Christian scholar is obliged
to learn from “Antiquities” and “Introductions”
and “Bible Dictionaries,” authenticated by universal and
orthodox approbation. These are the providential provisions of the Divine
Œconomy, for the communication of truth. Dr. Watts has a sermon on the
Inward Witness to Christianity
, which I find quoted by Vicesimus
Knox (Works, vol. vii. p. 73,
et seqq.
) in a choice passage
that forcibly expands and expounds some of Clement’s suggestions,
though without referring to our author.
VI.
(Justification, p. 305
note 7
.)
Without reference to my own views on this great
subject, and desiring merely to illustrate our author, it shall suffice
to remark, here, that to suppose that Clement uses the word
technically
, as we now use the language of the schools and of
post-Reformation theologians, would hopelessly confuse the argument of
our author. It is clear that he has no idea of any justification apart
from the merits of Christ: but he uses the term loosely to express his
idea, that as the Law led the Hebrews to the great Healer, who rose
from the dead for our justification, in that sense, and in no other,
the truth
that was to be found in Greek Philosophy, although a
minimum
, did the same for heathen who loved truth, and followed
it so far as they knew. Whether his views even in this were correct, it
would not become me, here, to express any opinion. (See below,
Elucidation XIV.)
VII.
(Philosophy, p. 305,
note 8
.)
It is so important to grasp just what our author
understands by this “philosophy,” that I had designed to
introduce, here, a long passage from Bishop Kaye’s lucid
exposition. Finding, however, that these elucidations are already,
perhaps, over multiplied, I content myself with a reference to his
Account
, etc. (pp. 118–121).
VIII.
(Overflow of the Spirit, p. 306,
note 1
.)
Here, again, I wished to introduce textual
citations from several eminent authors: I content myself with a very
short one from Kaye, to illustrate the intricacy, not to say the
contradictory character, of some of Clement’s positions as to the
extent of grace bestowed on the heathen. “Clement says that an
act, to be right, must be done through the love of God. He says that
every action of the heathen is sinful, since it is not sufficient that
an action is right:
its object or aim must also be right
”
(
Account,
etc., p. 426). For a most interesting, but I venture
to think overdrawn, statement of St. Paul’s position as to
heathen “wisdom,” etc., see Farrar’s
Life of St.
Paul
(p. 20,
et seqq.,
ed. New York). Without relying on
this popular author, I cannot but refer the reader to his
Hulsean
Lecture
(1870, p. 135,
et seqq.
).
IX.
(Faith without Learning, p. 307,
note 5
.)
The compassion of Christ for poverty, misery, for
childhood, and for ignorance, is everywhere illustrated in Holy
Scripture; and
faith
, even “as a grain of mustard
seed,” is magnified, accordingly, in the infinite love of his
teaching. Again I am willing to refer to Farrar (though I read him
always with something between the lines, before I can adopt his
sweeping generalizations) for a fine passage, I should quote entire,
did space permit (
The Witness of History to Christ
, p. 172, ed.
London, 1872). See also the noble sermon of Jeremy Taylor on
John vii.
17
(
Works
, vol. ii. p. 53, ed. Bohn, 1844).
X.
(The Open Secret, p. 313,
note 3
.)
The esoteric system of Clement is here
expounded in few words: there is nothing in it which may not be proclaimed
from the house-tops, for all who have ears to hear. It is the mere
swine (with seed-pickers and jack-daws, the
σπερμόλογοι
of the Athenians) who must be denied the pearls of gnostic truth. And
this, on the same merciful principle on which the Master was silent
before Pilate, and turned away from cities where they were not prepared
to receive his message.
XI.
(Bodily Purity, p. 317,
note 1
.)
From a familiar quotation, I have often argued that the
fine instinct of a woman, even among heathen, enforces a true idea:
“If from her husband’s bed, as soon as she has bathed: if
from adulterous commerce, not at all.” This is afterwards noted
by our author;
2150
but it is extraordinary to find the mind
of the great missionary to our Saxon forefathers, troubled about such
questions, even in the seventh century. I have less admiration for the
elaborate answers of the great Patriarch of Rome (Gregory), to the
scrupulous inquiries of Augustine, than for the instinctive and
aphoristic wisdom of poor Theano, in all the darkness of her
heathenism. (See Ven. Bede,
Eccles. Hist.
, book i. cap. 27, p.
131. Works, ed. London, 1843.)
XII.
(Clement’s View of
Philosophy, p. 318,
note 4
.)
I note the concluding words of this chapter
(xvi.), as epitomizing the whole of what Clement means to say on this
great subject; and, for more, see the Elucidation
infra
, on
Justification.
XIII.
(The Ecstacy of Sibyl, etc., p.
319,
note 3
.)
No need to quote Virgil’s description
(
Æneid,
vi. 46, with Heyne’s references in Excursus V.);
but I would compare with his picture of Sibylline inspiration, that of
Balaam (
Numbers 24:3, 4, 15, 16
), and leave with the student an
inquiry, how far we may credit to a divine motion, the oracles of the
heathen, i.e., some of them. I wish to refer the student, also, as to a
valuable bit of introductory learning, to the essay of Isaac Casaubon
(
Exercitationes ad Baronii Prolegom.
, pp. 65–85,
ed. Genevæ, 1663).
XIV.
(Justification, p. 323,
note 2
.)
Casaubon, in the work just quoted above
(
Exercitat.
, i.) examines this passage of our author, and
others, comparing them with passages from St. Chrysostom and St.
Augustine, and with Justin Martyr (see vol. i. p. 178, this series,
cap. 46). Bishop Kaye (p. 428) justly remarks: “The apparent
incorrectness of Clement’s language arises from not making that
clear distinction which the controversies at the time of the
Reformation introduced.” The word “incorrectness,”
though for myself I do not object to it, might be said “to beg
the question;” and hence I should prefer to leave it open to the
divers views of readers, by speaking, rather, of his lack of
precision
in the use of a term not then defined with theological
delicacy of statement.
XV.
(Chronology, p. 334,
note 5
.)
Here an invaluable work for comparison and reference
must be consulted by the student; viz., the
Chronicon
of
Julius Africanus, in Routh’s
Reliquiæ
(tom ii. p. 220,
et seqq
.), with learned annotations, in which (e.g., p. 491)
Clement’s work is cited. Africanus took up chronological science
in the imperfect state where it was left by Clement, with whom he was
partially contemporary; for he was Bishop of Emmaus in Palestine
(called also Nicopolis), and composed his fine books of chronological
history, under Marcus Aurelius.
2151
On the
Alexandrian era consult a paragraph in
Encyc. Britannica
(vol.
v. p. 714). It was adopted for Christian computation, after Africanus.
See Eusebius (book vi. cap. 31), and compare (this volume, p. 85) what
is said of Theophilus of Antioch, by Abp. Usher.
2152
2143
Book i.
cap. i. p. 299,
note 1.
2144
Ed
. Rivingtons, London,
1835.
2145
Book i. cap. i. p. 301,
note 9
.
2146
See Jones,
On the Canon
,
vol. iii. p. 44
2147
Antiquities
, vol. i. p. 66,
ed. Bohn.
2148
Book i. cap. i. p. 301,
note 10
.
2149
Book i. cap. i. p. 302,
note 5
.
2150
p. 428,
infra
.
2151
See also
Fragments
, p.
164, vol. ix. this series, Edin. Edition.
2152
For matters further pertaining to
Clement, consult Routh, i. 140, i. 148, i. 127, i. 169, ii. 59
(Eusebius, vi. 13), ii. 165, 167, 168, 171–172, 179, 307, 416,
491.