things not to be trusted.—God has directly taught his church to expect, that such religion
will fail; and that such men, having no higher principle, will return to their wickedness. Job
xxvii. 8, 9, 10. “The hypocrite—will he delight himself in the Almighty? will he always call
upon God?”—Dan. xii. 10. “The wicked will do wickedly.” And therefore God does not re-
quire his church to accept their profession and promises. If he has taught us not to credit
their profession and promises, then certainly he has taught us not to accept them.
III. Another argument against this supposed rule of allowing and requiring unsanctified
men with moral sincerity, to come to sacraments, is this. That rule, which if fully attended,
would naturally bring it to pass, that the greater part of communicants would be unfit, even
according to that very rule, cannot be a divine rule. But this supposed rule of moral sincerity
is such a rule. For if this rule be universally attended, then all unsanctified men, who have
present convictions of conscience sufficient to make them morally sincere, must come into
the communion of the church. But this conviction and common religion, if it do not issue
in conversion, (as has been observed,) commonly vanishes away in a short time. And yet
still these persons, if not convicted of open scandal, are left in the communion of the church,
and remain there, without even moral sincerity.—Experience gives us abundant reason to
think, that of those who some time or other have considerable convictions of conscience,
so as to make them for the present to be what is called morally sincere, but few are savingly
converted. 408 And if all these must be admitted, (as they must, if this rule be fully attended,)
then their convictions going away, and their sincerity vanishing with it, it will hereby be
brought about, that the Lord’s table is chiefly surrounded with the worst sort of morally in-
sincere persons, viz. stupid backsliders, that are in themselves far worse than they were before,
according to the scripture account, Matt. xii. 45. and 2 Pet. ii. 20.—And this as the natural
consequence of the forementioned rule, appointing moral sincerity to be the qualification
for communion. Thus this supposed rule supplants its own design.
505
IV. Another argument, that moral sincerity is not the qualification to which God has
annexed a lawful right to sacraments, is, that this qualification is not at all inconsistent with
a man’s living at the same time in the most heinous wickedness, in a superlative degree
contrary to the christian religion.
It was before observed to be a thing evident in itself, and allowed by Mr. W. that there
are some sins, which, while wilfully continued and lived in, though secretly, do wholly dis-
qualify persons for christian sacraments, and make it unlawful for men to partake of them.
Now if it be thus with some sins, doubtless it is because of the heinousness of those sins, the
high degree of wickedness which is in them. And hence it will follow, that those sins which
408 How small a proportion are there of the vast multitudes, that in the time of the late religious commotion
through the land had their consciences awakened who give hopeful abiding evidences of a saving conversion to
God!
1952
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.