§4. After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the Father, is
simple and uncompounded, and that, He Who redeemed us from bondage is not under
dominion of the Father, nor in a state of slavery: and that otherwise not He alone, but also
the Father Who is in the Son and is One with Him, must be a slave; and that the word “being”
is formed from the word to “be.” And having excellently and notably discussed all these matters,
he concludes the book.
But not yet has the most grievous part of his profanity been examined, which the sequel
of his treatise goes on to add. Well, let us consider his words sentence by sentence. Yet I
know not how I can dare to let my mouth utter the horrible and godless language of him
who fights against Christ. For I fear lest, like some baleful drugs, the remnant of the perni-
cious bitterness should be deposited upon the lips through which the words pass. “He that
cometh unto God,” says the Apostle, “must believe that He is952.” Accordingly, true existence
is the special distinction of Godhead. But Eunomius makes out Him Who truly is, either
not to exist at all, or not to exist in a proper sense, which is just the same as not existing at
all; for he who does not properly exist, does not really exist at all; as, for example, he is said
to “run” in a dream who in that state fancies he is exerting himself in the race, while, since
he untruly acts the semblance of the real race, his fancy that he is running is not for this
reason a race. But even though in an inexact sense it is so called, still the name is given to it
falsely. Accordingly, he who dares to assert that the Only-begotten God either does not
properly exist, or does not exist at all, manifestly blots out of his creed all faith in Him. For
who can any longer believe in something non-existent? or who would resort to Him Whose
being has been shown by the enemies of the true Lord to be improper and unsubstantial?
225
But that our statement may not be thought to be unfair to our opponents, I will set side
by side with it the language of the impious persons, which runs as follows:—“He Who is in
the bosom of the Existent, and Who is in the beginning and is with God, not being, or at all
events not being in a strict sense, even though Basil, neglecting this distinction and addition,
uses the title of ‘Existent’ interchangeably, contrary to the truth—” What do you say? that
He Who is in the Father is not, and that He Who is in the beginning, and Who is in the
bosom of the Father, is not, for this very reason, that He is in the beginning and is in the
Father, and is discerned in the bosom of the Existent, and hence does not in a strict sense
exist, because He is in the Existent? Alas for the idle and irrational tenets! Now for the first
time we have heard this piece of vain babbling,—that the Lord, by Whom are all things,
does not in a strict sense exist. And we have not yet got to the end of this appalling statement;
but something yet more startling remains behind, that he not only affirms that He does not
exist, or does not strictly speaking exist, but also that the Nature in which He is conceived
to reside is various and composite. For he says “not being, or not being simple.” But that to
952 Heb. xi. 6.
After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the Father, is simple and uncompounded, and that, He Who redeemed us from bondage is not under dominion of the Father, nor in a state of slavery: and that otherwise not He alone, but also the Father Who is in the Son and is One with Him, must be a slave; and that the word “being” is formed from the word to “be.” And having excellently and notably discussed all these matters, he concludes the book.
431
After this he shows that the Son, who truly is, and is in the bosom of the…