which condemned Paul of Samosata, and he contends that both councils were orthodox,
since they used homousios in a different sense. As a parallel instance he takes the word
ἀγέννητος which like homousios is not a scriptural word, and like it also is used in two ways,
signifying either (1) Τὸ ὂν μεν, μήτε δὲ γεννηθὲν μήτε ὅλως ἔχον τὸν αἴτιον, or (2) Τὸ
ἄκτιστον. In the former sense the Son cannot be called ἀγέννητος, in the latter he may be
so called. Both uses, he says, are found in the fathers. Of the latter he quotes the passage
in Ignatius as an example; of the former he says, that some writers subsequent to Ignatius
declare ἕν τὸ ἀγέννητον ὁ πατὴρ, καὶ εἶς ὁ ἐξ αὐτου υἱὸς γνήσιος, γέννημα αληθίνον κ.τ.λ.
[He may have been thinking of Clem. Alex. Strom. vi. 7, which I shall quote below.] He
maintains that both are orthodox, as having in view two different senses of the word
ἀγέννητον , and the same, he argues, is the case with the councils which seem to take opposite
sides with regard to homousios. It is clear from this passage, as Zahn truly says, that Ath-
anasius is dealing with one and the same word throughout; and, if so, it follows that this
word must be ἀγέννητον, since ἀγένητον would be intolerable in some places. I may add
by way of caution that in two other passages, de Decret. Syn. Nic. 28 (1, p. 184), Orat. c.
Arian. i. 30 (1, p. 343), St. Athanasius gives the various senses of ἀγένητον (for this is plain
from the context), and that these passages ought not to be treated as parallels to the present
passage which is concerned with the senses of ἀγέννητον . Much confusion is thus created,
e.g. in Newman’s notes on the several passages in the Oxford translation of Athanasius (pp.
51 sq., 224 sq.), where the three passages are treated as parallel, and no attempt is made to
discriminate the readings in the several places, but “ingenerate” is given as the rendering of
both alike. If then Athanasius who read γεννητὸς καὶ ἀγέννητος in Ignatius, there is abso-
lutely no authority for the spelling with one ν. The earlier editors (Voss, Ussher, Cotelier,
etc.), printed it as they found it in the ms.; but Smith substituted the forms with the single
ν, and he has been followed more recently by Hefele, Dressel, and some other. In the Cas-
6
anatensian copy of the ms., a marginal note is added, ἀναγνωστέον ἀγένητος τοῦτ᾽ ἔστι μὴ
ποιηθείς. Waterland (Works, III., p. 240 sq., Oxf. 1823) tries ineffectually to show that the
form with the double ν was invented by the fathers at a later date to express their theological
conception. He even “doubts whether there was any such word as ἀγέννητος so early as
the time of Ignatius.” In this he is certainly wrong.
The mss. of early Christian writers exhibit much confusion between these words spelled
with the double and the single ν. See e.g. Justin Dial. 2, with Otto’s note; Athenag. Suppl. 4
with Otto’s note; Theophil, ad Autol. ii. 3, 4; Iren. iv. 38, 1, 3; Orig. c. Cels. vi. 66; Method.
de Lib. Arbitr., p. 57; Jahn (see Jahn’s note 11, p. 122); Maximus in Euseb. Præp. Ev. vii. 22;
Hippol. Hær. v. 16 (from Sibylline Oracles); Clem. Alex. Strom. v. 14; and very frequently
in later writers. Yet notwithstanding the confusion into which later transcribers have thus
thrown the subject, it is still possible to ascertain the main facts respecting the usage of the
two forms. The distinction between the two terms, as indicated by their origin, is that
46
Excursus on the Words .”