§3. Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.
The whole Christian world has reason to be thankful that there lived at the opening of
the fourth century a man who, with his life spanning one of the greatest epochs that has
occurred in the history of the Church, with an intimate experimental knowledge of the old
and of the new condition of things, was able to conceive so grand a plan and possessed the
means and the ability to carry it out. Had he written nothing else, Eusebius’ Church History
would have made him immortal; for if immortality be a fitting reward for large and lasting
services, few possess a clearer title to it than the author of that work. The value of the History
to us lies not in its literary merit, but in the wealth of the materials which it furnishes for a
knowledge of the early Church. How many prominent figures of the first three centuries
are known to us only from the pages of Eusebius; how many fragments, priceless on account
of the light which they shed upon movements of momentous and far-reaching consequence,
have been preserved by him alone; how often a hint dropped, a casual statement made in
passing, or the mention of some apparently trifling event, gives the clue which enables us
to unravel some perplexing labyrinth, or to fit into one whole various disconnected and
apparently unrelated elements, and thus to trace the steps in the development of some im-
47
portant historical movement whose rise and whose bearing must otherwise remain an un-
solved riddle. The work reveals no sympathy with Ebionism, Gnosticism, and Montanism,
and little appreciation of their real nature, and yet our knowledge of their true significance
and of their place in history is due in considerable part to facts respecting the movements
or their leaders which Eusebius alone has recorded or preserved. To understand the devel-
opment of the Logos Christology we must comprehend the significance of the teaching of
Paul of Samosata, and how inadequate would our knowledge of the nature of that teaching
be without the epistle quoted in Book VII. chap. 30. How momentous were the consequences
of the paschal controversies, and how dark would they be were it not for the light shed upon
them by our author. How important, in spite of their tantalizing brevity and obscurity, the
fragments of Papias’ writings; how interesting the extracts from the memoirs of Hegesippus;
how suggestive the meager notices from Dionysius of Corinth, from Victor of Rome, from
Melito, from Caius; how instructive the long and numerous quotations from the epistles of
Dionysius of Alexandria! He may often fail to appreciate the significance of the events which
he records, he may in many cases draw unwarranted conclusions from the premises which
he states, he may sometimes misinterpret his documents and misunderstand men and
movements, but in the majority of cases he presents us with the material upon which to
form our own judgments, and if we differ with him we must at the same time thank him
for the data which have enabled us independently to reach other results.
But the value of Eusebius’ Church History does not lie solely in the fact that it contains
so many original sources which would be otherwise unknown to us. It is not merely a
thesaurus, it is a history in the truest sense, and it possesses an intrinsic value of its own,
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.
71
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his History.