106 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK III.
in which angels was certainly the Father, and the Son, and the
Holy Spirit ; and in which sometimes the Father, sometimes
the Son, and sometimes the Holy Spirit, sometimes, without
any distinction of person, God was figuratively signified by
them, although appearing in visible and sensible forms, yet
by His own creature, not by His substance, in order to the
seeing of which hearts are cleansed through all those things
which are seen by the eyes and heard by the ears.
27. But now, as I think, that which we had undertaken to
show in this book has been sufficiently discussed and demon-
strated, according to our capacity ; and it has been established,
both by probable reason, so far as a man, or rather, so far as I
am able, and by strength of authority, so far as the divine
declarations from the Holy Scriptures have been made clear,
that those words and bodily appearances which were given to
these ancient fathers of ours before the incarnation of the
Saviour, when God was said to appear, were wrought by
angels : whether themselves speaking or doing something in
the person of God, as we have shown that the prophets also
were wont to do, or assuming from the creature that which
they themselves were not, wherein God might be shown in a
figure to men ; which manner of figure also. Scripture teaches
by many examples, that the prophets, too, did not omit. It
remains, therefore, now for us to consider,—since both in the
Lord as born of a virgin, and in the Holy Spirit descending in
a corporeal form like a dove,^ and in the tongues like as of
fire, w^hich appeared with a sound from heaven on the day of
Pentecost, after the ascension of the Lord,^ it was not the
Word of God Himself by His own substance, in which He
is equal and co-eternal with the Father, nor the Spirit of the
Father and of the Son by His own substance, in which He
Himself also is equal and co-eternal with both, but assuredly
a creature, such as could be formed and exist in these fashions,
which appeared to corporeal and mortal senses,—it remains, I
say, to consider what difference there is between these manifes-
tations and those which were proper to the Son ofGod and to the
Holy Spirit, although wrought by the visible creature ; which
subject we shall more conveniently begin in another book.
^ Matt. iii. 16. 2^cts ii. 1-4