tenor of their conduct, as they neglected and opposed the most proper means of calmly
considering, and so of thoroughly understanding, the matter in dispute, and persisted in a
refusal to attend to what Mr. Edwards had to say, in defence of his principles. From the be-
ginning to the end, they opposed the measures, which had the best tendency to compromise
and heal the difficulty; and with much zeal pursued those, which were calculated to make
a separation certain and speedy. He thought of preaching on the subject, that they might
know what were his sentiments and the grounds of them, (of both which he was sensible
that most of them were quite ignorant,) before they took any steps for a separation. But that
he might do nothing to increase the tumult, he first proposed the thing to the standing
committee of the church; supposing, that if he entered on the subject publicly with their
consent, it would prevent the ill consequences, which otherwise he feared would follow. But
the most of them strenuously opposed it. Upon which he gave it over for the present, as
what, in such circumstances, would rather blow up the fire to a greater height, than answer
the good ends proposed.”
Mr. Edwards was sensible that his principles were not understood, but misrepresented
through the country; and finding that his people were too warm, calmly to attend to the
matter in controversy, he proposed to print what he had to say on the point, as this seemed
the only way left him to have a fair hearing. Accordingly his people consented to put off
calling a council, till what he should write was published. With this view he began immedi-
ately to prepare a statement and defence of his own sentiments, and in the latter part of
April, about two months from the time of its commencement, sent it to the press—an instance
of rapidity of composition almost unexampled in an individual, who was at once occupied
by the duties of an extensive parish, and involved in the embarrassments of a most perplexing
controversy. Notwithstanding the efforts of Mr. Edwards, the printing of the work was not
completed until August. It was entitled, “An Humble Inquiry into the Rules of the Word of
God, concerning the Qualifications requisite to a Complete Standing and Full Communion
in the Visible Christian Church;” and contains a discussion of the question agitated between
himself and his people, “Whether any persons ought to be admitted to full communion in
the christian church, but such as, in the eye of a reasonable judgment, are truly Christi-
ans?”—a discussion so thorough and conclusive, that it has been the standard work with
evangelical divines from that time to the present.
It was a very painful consideration to Mr. Edwards, that, while the circumstances in
which he was placed, constrained him to declare his sentiments from the press, the ”Appeal
to the Learned,“ the production of a man so much loved and venerated at Northampton,
and so much respected throughout New England, his own colleague too, and his own
grandfather, was the work, and the only work of any respectability, on the opposite side of
the question, which he should be obliged publicly to examine and refute. But his feelings
on this subject he has himself explained. “It is far from a pleasing circumstance of this
237
CHAPTER XVI. Commencement of difficulties at Northampton