through the bright cloud, thus proclaimed Him; for “This,” He saith, “is My beloved Son611.”
Yet, though I was taught that He is the Son, I was not dragged down by the name to the
earthly significance of “Son,” but I both know that He is from the Father and do not know
that He is from passion. And this, moreover, I will add to what has been said, that I know
even a bodily generation which is pure from passion, so that even on this point Eunomius’
physiology of bodily generation is proved false, if, that is to say, a bodily birth can be found
which does not admit passion. Tell me, was the Word made flesh, or not? You would not,
I presume, say that It was not. It was so made, then, and there is none who denies it. How
then was it that “God was manifested in the flesh612”? “By birth,” of course you will say. But
what sort of birth do you speak of? Surely it is clear that you speak of that from the virginity,
and that “that which was conceived in her was of the Holy Ghost613,” and that “the days
were accomplished that she should be delivered, and she brought forth614,” and none the
less was her purity preserved in her child-bearing. You believe, then, that that birth which
took place from a woman was pure from passion, if you do believe, but you refuse to admit
the Divine and incorruptible generation from the Father, that you may avoid the idea of
passion in generation. But I know well that it is not passion he seeks to avoid in his doctrine,
for that he does not discern at all in the Divine and incorruptible nature; but to the end that
the Maker of all creation may be accounted a part of creation, he builds up these arguments
in order to a denial of the Only-begotten God, and uses his pretended caution about passion
to help him in his task.
611 S. Matt. xvii. 5.
612 1 Tim. iii. 16. Here, as elsewhere in Gregory’s writings, it appears that he read θεὸς in this passage.
613 S. Matt. i. 20
614 S. Luke ii. 6, 7.
297
The fourth book discusses the account of the nature of the “product of generation,”…