Chapter 7.—11. For in fact, as to what some opposed to the reasoning of Cyprian, that
the apostle says, "Notwithstanding every way, whether in pretence or in truth, let Christ be
preached;"1369 Cyprian rightly exposed their error, showing that it has nothing to do with
the case of heretics, since the apostle was speaking of those who were acting within the
Church, with malicious envy seeking their own profit. They announced Christ, indeed,
according to the truth whereby we believe in Christ, but not in the spirit in which He was
announced by the good evangelists to the sons of the dove. "For Paul," he says, "in his epistle
was not speaking of heretics, or of their baptism, so that it could be shown that he had laid
down anything concerning this matter. He was speaking of brethren, whether as walking
disorderly and contrary to the discipline of the Church, or as keeping the discipline of the
Church in the fear of God. And he declared that some of them spoke the word of God
steadfastly and fearlessly, but that some were acting in envy and strife; that some had kept
themselves encompassed with kindly Christian love, but that others entertained malice and
strife: but yet that he patiently endured all things, with the view that, whether in truth or
in pretence, the name of Christ, which Paul preached, might come to the knowledge of the
greatest number, and that the sowing of the word, which was as yet a new and unaccustomed
work, might spread more widely by the preaching of those that spoke. Furthermore, it is
one thing for those who are within the Church to speak in the name of Christ, another thing
for those who are without, acting against the Church, to baptize in the name of Christ."1370
These words of Cyprian seem to warn us that we must distinguish between those who are
bad outside, and those who are bad within the Church. And those whom he says that the
apostle represents as preaching the gospel impurely and of envy, he says truly were within.
This much, however, I think I may say without rashness, if no one outside can have anything
which is of Christ, neither can any one within have anything which is of the devil. For if
that closed garden can contain the thorns of the devil, why cannot the fountain of Christ
equally flow beyond the garden’s bounds? But if it cannot contain them, whence, even in
the time of the Apostle Paul himself, did there arise amongst those who were within so great
an evil of envy and malicious strife? For these are the words of Cyprian. Can it be that envy
and malicious strife are a small evil? How then were those in unity who were not at peace?
For it is not my voice, nor that of any man, but of the Lord Himself; nor did the sound go
forth from men, but from angels, at the birth of Christ, "Glory to God in the highest, and
on earth peace to men of good will."1371 And this certainly would not have been proclaimed
by the voice of angels when Christ was born upon the earth, unless God wished this to be
1369 Phil. i. 18. Hieron. "annuntietur."
1370 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. 14.
1371 Luke ii. 14. "Hominibus bonæ voluntatis;" and so the Vulgate, following the reading ἐν ἀνθρώποις
εὐδοκίας.
Chapter 7
792
Chapter 7