410
two authors, and from Clement, in particular, whole sentences are taken unchanged.3222
Yet the only reference made to either is the very general allusion in the third and fourth
books.3223
On the other hand, he quotes frequently and refers distinctly to many authors, and is
especially careful to show that he has good authority for his statements, as will be seen by
observing the number of books to which he refers on the mysteries and temples. If we bear
this in mind, the principle which guided him seems to have been, that when he has occasion
to quote an author once or twice, he does so by name, but that he takes it for granted that
every one knows what are the great sources of information, and that it is therefore unneces-
sary to specify in each case what is the particular authority.
There are many interesting questions connected with his subject, but these we must for
the present leave untouched.
6. No other works by Arnobius have been preserved, and only two mss. are known to
exist. Of these, the one in Brussels is merely a transcript of that preserved in the public library
at Paris, on which all editions have been based. This is a ms. of the ninth or tenth century,
and contains the Octavius of Minucius Felix immediately after the seventh book adversus
Gentes, in consequence of which that treatise was at first printed as the eighth book of
Arnobius. Although it has been collated several times, we are still in doubt as to its true
readings,—Hildebrand, who last examined it, having done so with too little care.
The first3224 edition was printed at Rome in 1542, and was followed by that of Geleni-
us,3225 in which much was done for the emendation of the text; but arbitrary conjectures
were too frequently admitted. Next in order follow those of Canterus,3226 who did especial
service by pointing out what use Arnobius has made of Clement, Ursinus,3227 Elmen-
horst,3228 Stewechius,3229 Heraldus,3230 and the Leyden3231 variorum edition, based on a
3222 [Compare the Exhortation of Clement, vol. ii. p. 171, passim; and Tertullian, vol. iii. and passim.]
3223 Book iii. cap. 7, and book iv. cap. 13, note.
3224 Arnobii Disputationum adversus Gentes, libri octo, nunc primum in lucem editi Romæ, apud Franc.
Priscianum Florentinum, 1542.
3225 Basileæ, 1546.
3226 Antverpiæ, 1582.
3227 Romæ, 1583. This is the second Roman edition, and restores the Octavius to Minucius Felix.
3228 Hanoviæ, 1603; dedicated to Joseph Scaliger.
3229 Antverpiæ, 1604.
3230 Paris, 1605. This edition, which is of great value, and shows great learning and ability, was completed
in two months, as Heraldus himself tells us.
3231 Lugduni Batavorum 1651, containing the notes of Canterus, Elmenhorst, Stewechius, and Heraldus.
913
Introductory Notice.