Scipio Maffei, Dell’ impiego dell danaro, written on the laxer side, having attracted a wide-
spread attention. The Ballerini affirm that the learned pope Benedict XIV. allowed books
defending the new morals to be dedicated to him, and in 1830 the Congregation of the Holy
Office with the approval of the reigning Pontiff, Pius VIII., decided that those who considered
the taking of interest allowed by the state law justifiable, were “not to be disturbed.” It is
entirely disingenuous to attempt to reconcile the modern with the ancient doctrine; the
Fathers expressly deny that the State has any power to make the receiving of interest just or
to fix its rate, there is but one ground for those to take who accept the new teaching, viz.
that all the ancients, while true on the moral principle that one must not defraud his
neighbour nor take unjust advantage of his necessity, were in error concerning the facts, in
that they supposed that money was barren, an opinion which the Schoolmen also held, fol-
lowing Aristotle. This we have found in modern times, and amid modern circumstances,
to be an entire error, as Gury, the famous modern casuist, well says, “fructum producit et
multiplicatur per se.”99
That the student may have it in his power to read the Patristic view of the matter, I give
a list of the passages most commonly cited, together with a review of the conciliar action,
for all which I am indebted to a masterly article by Wharton B. Marriott in Smith and
Cheetham’s Dictionary of Christian Antiquities (s.v. Usury).
Although the conditions of the mercantile community in the East and the West differed
materially in some respects, the fathers of the two churches are equally explicit and system-
atic in their condemnation of the practice of usury. Among those belonging to the Greek
church we find Athanasius (Expos. in Ps. xiv); Basil the Great (Hom. in Ps. xiv). Gregory of
Nazianzum (Orat. xiv. in Patrem tacentem). Gregory of Nyssa (Orat. cont. Usurarios); Cyril
of Jerusalem (Catech. iv. c. 37), Epiphanius (adv. Hæres. Epilog. c. 24), Chrysostom (Hom.
xli. in Genes), and Theodoret (Interpr. in Ps. xiv. 5, and liv. 11). Among those belonging to
the Latin church, Hilary of Poitiers (in Ps. xiv); Ambrose (de Tobia liber unus). Jerome (in
Ezech. vi. 18); Augustine de Baptismo contr. Donatistas, iv. 19); Leo the Great (Epist. iii. 4),
and Cassiodorus (in Ps. xiv. 10).
The canons of later councils differ materially in relation to this subject, and indicate a
distinct tendency to mitigate the rigour of the Nicæan interdict. That of the council of
Carthage of the year 348 enforces the original prohibition, but without the penalty, and
grounds the veto on both Old and New Testament authority, “nemo contra prophetas, nemo
contra evangelia facit sine periculo” (Mansi, iii. 158). The language, however, when compared
with that of the council of Carthage of the year 419, serves to suggest that, in the interval,
the lower clergy had occasionally been found having recourse to the forbidden practice, for
99 Gury, Comp. Theol. Moral (Ed. Ballerini) vol. ii. p. 611.
100
Excursus on Usury.