III.—From the Books Against Sabellius.718 On the Notion that Matter is Ungenerated.719
————————————
These certainly are not to be deemed pious who hold that matter is ungenerated, while
they allow, indeed, that it is brought under the hand of God so far as its arrangement and
regulation are concerned; for they do admit that, being naturally passive720 and pliable, it
yields readily to the alterations impressed upon it by God. It is for them, however, to show
us plainly how it can possibly be that the like and the unlike should be predicated as subsisting
together in God and matter. For it becomes necessary thus to think of one as a superior to
either, and that is a thought which cannot legitimately be entertained with regard to God.
For if there is this defect of generation which is said to be the thing like in both, and if there
is this point of difference which is conceived of besides in the two, whence has this arisen
in them? If, indeed, God is the ungenerated, and if this defect of generation is, as we may
say, His very essence, then matter cannot be ungenerated; for God and matter are not one
and the same. But if each subsists properly and independently—namely, God and mat-
ter—and if the defect of generation also belongs to both, then it is evident that there is
something different from each, and older and higher than both. But the difference of their
contrasted constitutions is completely subversive of the idea that these can subsist on an
equality together, and more, that this one of the two—namely, matter—can subsist of itself.
For then they will have to furnish an explanation of the fact that, though both are supposed
to be ungenerated, God is nevertheless impassible, immutable, imperturbable, energetic;
while matter is the opposite, impressible, mutable, variable, alterable. And now, how can
these properties harmoniously co-exist and unite? Is it that God has adapted Himself to the
nature of the matter, and thus has skilfully wrought it? But it would be absurd to suppose
that God works in gold, as men are wont to do, or hews or polishes stone, or puts His hand
to any of the other arts by which different kinds of matter are made capable of receiving
form and figure. But if, on the other hand, He has fashioned matter according to His own
will, and after the dictates of His own wisdom, impressing upon it the rich and manifold
forms produced by His own operation, then is this account of ours one both good and true,
718 In Eusebius, Præpar. Evangel., book vii. ch. 19.
719 Eusebius introduces this extract thus: “And I shall adduce the words of those who have most thoroughly
examined the dogma before us, and first of all Dionysius indeed, who, in the first book of his Exercitations
against Sabellius, writes in these terms on the subject in hand.” [Note the primary position of our author in the
refutation of Sabellianism, and see (vol. v.) the story of Callistus.]
720 παθητήν.
From the Books Against Sabellius. On the Notion that Matter is Ungenerated.
206
From the Books Against Sabellius. On the Notion that Matter is Ungenera…