Elucidations.
————————————
Neale, in his valuable work,268 does full justice to Dionysius, whose life is twinned with
Gregory’s; but he seems to me most unaccountably to slight the truly great and commanding
genius of Gregory. I take opportunity, then, to direct attention to Neale’s candid, and, on
the whole, favourable view of Origen; but it grieves me whenever I see in critics a manifest
inability to put themselves back into the times of which they write, as I think is the case, not
infrequently, even with Dr. Neale. The figure of this grand ornament of the mighty patri-
archate and school of Alexandria is colossal.269 His genius is Titanic, and has left all
Christendom profoundly his debtor to this day, by the variety of his work and the versatility
of his speech and pen. Doubtless the youthful Gregory’s panegyric does contain, as he
himself suggests, much that is “puerile or bordering on flattery;” but, as he protests with
transparent truthfulness, “there is nothing in it unreal.” It shines with “sincerity of thought
and integrity of judgment.” And as such, what a portrait it presents us of the love and patient
effort of this lifelong confessor! Let me commend this example to professors of theology
generally. All can learn from it the power of sweetness and love, united with holiness of
purpose, to stamp the minds and the characters of youth with the divine “image and super-
scription.”
But, as to the sharpness of modern censures upon Origen’s conspicuous faults, I must
suggest three important considerations, which should be applied to all the Ante-Nicene
doctors: (1) How could they who were working out the formulas of orthodoxy, be expected
to use phrases with the skill and precision which became necessary only after the great
Synodical period had embodied them in clear, dogmatic statements? (2) How could the
active intellect of an Origen have failed to make great mistakes in such an immensity of la-
bours and such a variety of works? (3) If, in our own day, we indulge speculative minds in
large liberties so long as they never make shipwreck of the faith, how much more should
we deem them excusable who were unable to consult libraries of well-digested thought, and
to employ, as we do, the accumulated wealth of fifty generations of believers, whenever we
are called to the solemn responsibility of impressing our convictions upon others? The
conclusion of Dr. Neale’s review of Origen balances the praise and blame accorded to him
by those nearest to his times;270 but let us reflect upon the painful conflicts of those times,
and upon the pressure under which, to justify their own positions, they were often forced
to object to any error glorified by even the apparent patronage of Origen.
268 The Patriarchate of Alexandria, London, 1847.
269 The ultimate influence of the school itself, Neale pronounces “an enigma” (vol. i. p. 38).
270 Vol. i. p. 33.
Elucidations.
91
Elucidations.