Canon V.
(Probably adopted at a Council held in Constantinople the next year, 382. Vide. Intro-
duction on the number of the Canons.)
In regard to the tome of the Western [Bishops], we receive those in Antioch also who
confess the unity of the Godhead of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon V.
The Tome of the Westerns which recognizes the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit
as consubstantial is highly acceptable.
Beveridge and Van Espen translate this canon differently, thus, “With regard to the
tome of the Westerns, we agree with those in Antioch [i.e. the Synod of 378] who (accepted
it and) acknowledged the unity of the Godhead of the Father etc.” In opposition to this
translation Hefele urges that ἀποδέχεσθαι in ecclesiastical language usually refers to receiving
persons and recognizing them, not opinions or doctrines.
Hefele.
This canon probably does not belong to the second General Council, but to the Synod
held in the following year at Constantinople consisting of nearly the same bishops.
It is certain that by the “Tome of the Westerns” a dogmatic work of the Western bishops
is to be understood, and the only question is which Tome of the Westerns is here meant.
Several—for instance, the Greek commentators, Balsamon and Zonaras, and the spokesman
of the Latins at the Synod of Florence in 1439 (Archbishop Andrew of Rhodes)—understood
182
by it the decrees of the Synod of Sardica; but it seems to me that this canon undoubtedly
indicates that the Tome of the Westerns also mentioned the condition of the Antiochian
Church, and the division into two parties of the orthodox of that place—the Meletian schism.
Now, as this was not mentioned, nay, could not have been, at the Synod of Sardica—for this
schism at Antioch only broke out seventeen years later—some other document of the Latins
must certainly be meant. But we know that Pope Damasus, and the synod assembled by
him in 369, addressed a Tome to the Orientals, of which fragments are still preserved, and
that nine years later, in 379, a great synod at Antioch of one hundred and forty-six orthodox
Oriental bishops, under Meletius, accepted and signed this Tome, and at the same time
sought to put a stop to the Meletian schism. Soon afterwards, in 380, Pope Damasus and
his fourth Roman Synod again sent a treatise on the faith, of which we still possess a portion,
containing anathemas, to the Orientals, especially to Bishop Paul of Antioch, head of the
Eustathians of that city. Under these circumstances, we are justified in referring the expres-
sion “the tome of the Westerns” either to the Roman treatise of 369 or to that of 380, and I
am disposed to give the preference to the former, for the following reasons:—
(1.) As has been already observed, this canon belongs to the Synod held at Con-
stantinople in 382.
Canon V.
356
Canon V.