If then he says that goodness belongs to the Father only, he cuts off these from every con-
ceivable object in existence except the Father, so that, along with all, the Only-begotten God
is shut out from good. For as he who affirms that man alone is capable of laughter implies
thereby that no other animal shares this property, so he who asserts that good is in the
Father alone separates all things from that property. If then, as Eunomius declares, the
Father alone has by right the title of “good,” such a term will not be properly applied to
anything else. But every impulse of the will either operates in accordance with good, or tends
to the contrary. For to be inclined neither one way nor the other, but to remain in a state of
equipoise, is the property of creatures inanimate or insensible. If the Father alone is good,
having goodness not as a thing acquired, but in His nature, and if the Son, as heresy will
have it, does not share in the nature of the Father, then he who does not share the good es-
sence of the Father is of course at the same time excluded also from part and lot in the title
231
of “good.” But he who has no claim either to the nature or to the name of “good”—what he
is assuredly not unknown, even though I forbear the blasphemous expression. For it is plain
to all that the object for which Eunomius is so eager is to import into the conception of the
Son a suspicion of that which is evil and opposite to good. For what kind of name belongs
to him who is not good is manifest to every one who has a share of reason. As he who is not
brave is cowardly, as he who is not just is unjust, and as he who is not wise is foolish, so he
who is not good clearly has as his own the opposite name, and it is to this that the enemy
of Christ wishes to press the conception of the Only-begotten, becoming thereby to the
Church another Manes or Bardesanes. These are the sayings in regard of which we say that
our utterance would be no more effective than silence. For were one to say countless things,
and to arouse all possible arguments, one could not say anything so damaging of our oppon-
ents as what is openly and undisguisedly proclaimed by themselves. For what more bitter
charge could one invent against them for malice than that of denying that He is good “Who,
being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God972,” but yet condes-
cended to the low estate of human nature, and did so solely for the love of man? In return
for what, tell me, “do ye thus requite the Lord973?” (for I will borrow the language of Moses
to the Israelites); is He not good, Who when thou wast soulless dust invested thee with
Godlike beauty, and raised thee up as an image of His own power endowed with soul? Is
He not good, Who for thy sake took on Him the form of a servant, and for the joy set before
Him974 did not shrink from bearing the sufferings due to thy sin, and gave Himself a ransom
for thy death, and became for our sakes a curse and sin?
972 Cf. Phil. ii. 6
973 Deut. xxxii. 6.
974 Heb. xii. 2.
440
The eleventh book shows that the title of “Good” is due, not to the Father…