to the Gospel of the beauty of the Blessed God.”1351 His Power cannot be denied, of Whom
the Father saith: “I have laid help upon One that is mighty.”1352 And who dare refuse to
acknowledge Him to be immortal, when He Himself hath made others also immortal, as it
is written of the Wisdom of God: “By her shall I possess immortality.”1353
19. But the immortality of His Nature is one thing, that of ours is another. Things per-
ishable are not to be compared to things divine. The Godhead is the one only Substance
that death cannot touch, and therefore it is that the Apostle, though knowing both the [hu-
man] soul and angels to be immortal, declared that God only had immortality. In truth,
even the soul may die: “The soul that sinneth, it shall die,”1354 and an angel is not absolutely
immortal, his immortality depending on the will of the Creator.1355
20. Do not hastily reject this, because Gabriel dies not, nor Raphaël, nor Uriel.1356 Even
in their nature there is a capacity of sin, though not one of improvement by discipline,1357
1351 1 Tim. i. 11.
1352 Ps. lxxxix 19.
1353 Wisd. viii. 13.
1354 Ezek. xviii. 20.
1355 “That is to say, immortality is not of the essential nature of an angel as it is of the essential Nature of
God. For God’s existence is such that He necessarily exists, He cannot but exist; His existence is not derived
from another, but is from the power of His essential Nature, or rather is that very Nature. Not so with the angel,
whose existence is a gift of God, and so the angel’s existence is no part of the idea of an angel, but is a property
which is, so to speak, added on from without and accessory to the conception of such a being. Hence, in so far
as an angel’s existence issues not of the mere force of his essential properties, but only of the Creator’s Will, we
may say that by virtue of the said Will, not by force of his own nature, he continues in existence, and so far is
immortal, although in another sense immortality may be called a natural property of an angel, inasmuch as
there is no created power whereby he may be destroyed, and nothing in him that renders him liable to be destroyed
by God—nay rather, everything about him demands that, once he is created, he should be for ever preserved in
being.”—H.
1356 Hurter observes that St. Ambrose understands mortality in a wide sense, as including the capacity of
any and every sort of change. Immortality, then, in accordance with this definition, would connote perfect absence
of change. Hurter cites St. Bernard, § 81 in Cant.: “Omnis mutatio quædam mortis imitatio…Si tot mortes quot
mutationes, ubi immortalitas?” and Plutarch, in Eusebius, Præpar. Ev. XI. 12. Plutarch’s view perhaps owed
something to study of the reliques of Herachtus. Many fathers expounded 1 Tim. vi. 16 on this definition of
immortality as=immutability. This definition would exclude angels, who are naturally fallible (as the rebellion
of Lucifer and the third part of the host of heaven proved)—or if they are now no longer fallible, they owe it not
to their own natural constitution but to grace. In so far then as angels are mutable, whether for better or worse,
they are not immortal.
1357 Angels being by nature mutable, either for better or for worse, that is, capable of good or evil, and so of
death, are de facto sinless, and hence need not, are not meet to be placed under, penal discipline. Or the meaning
546
Chapter III. That the Father and the Son must not be divided is proved by…