§34. The Passage where he attacks the ‘Ομοούσιον, and the contention in answer to it.
I will omit to speak of the words which occur before this passage which has been quoted.
They contain merely shameless abuse of our Master and Father in God, and nothing bearing
on the matter in hand. But on the passage itself, as he advances by the device of this terrible
dilemma a double-edged refutation, we cannot be silent; we must accept the intellectual
challenge, and fight for the Faith with all the power we have, and show that the formidable
two-edged sword which he has sharpened is feebler than a make-believe in a scene-painting.
He attacks the community of substance with two suppositions; he says that we either
name as Father and as Son two independent principles drawn out parallel to each other,
and then say that one of these existencies is produced by the other existence: or else we say
that one and the same essence is conceived of, participating in both names in turn, both
being172 Father, and becoming Son, and itself produced in generation from itself. I put this
in my own words, thereby not misinterpreting his thought, but only correcting the tumid
exaggeration of its expression, in such a way as to reveal his meaning by clearer words and
afford a comprehensive view of it. Having blamed us for want of polish and for having
brought to the controversy an insufficient amount of learning, he decks out his own work
in such a glitter of style, and passes the nail173, to use his own phrase, so often over his own
sentences, and makes his periods so smart with this elaborate prettiness, that he captivates
the reader at once with the attractions of language; such amongst many others is the passage
we have just recited by way of preface. We will, by leave, again recite it. “And so the scolding
you have given is only a halter, not to be eluded, which you have woven for your own necks;
justice, as might have been expected, records in your own words a verdict against yourselves.”
Observe these flowers of the old Attic; what polished brilliance of diction plays over his
composition; what a delicate and subtle charm of style is in bloom there! However, let this
be as people think. Our course requires us again to turn to the thought in those words; let
us plunge once more into the phrases of this pamphleteer. “Either you conceive of the beings
as separated and independent of each other, and then bring down one of them, by generation,
to the rank of Son, and contend that One who exists independently nevertheless was made
by means of the Other existence.” That is enough for the present. He says, then, that we
preach174 two causeless Beings. How can this man, who is always accusing us of levelling
80
and confusing, assert this from our believing, as we do, in a single substance of Both. If two
natures, alien to each other on the score of their being, were preached by our Faith, just as
it is preached by the Anomœan school, then there would be good reason for thinking that
this distinction of natures led to the supposition of two causeless beings. But if, as is the
172 Reading οὖσαν for οὐσίαν of Oehler and Migne.
173 ἐξουυχίζει
174 πρεσβεύειν. So Lucian. Diog. Laert., and Origen passim.
The Passage where he attacks the ῾Ομοούσιον, and the contention in answer to it.
152
The Passage where he attacks the μ , and the contention in answer…