but a visibility of circumcision of heart, or saving conversion, that is a necessary requisite to
a person’s coming to the Lord’s table. And in what manner this must be visible, he signifies
elsewhere, when he allows, that it must be so to a judgment of charity; a judgment of rational
charity. This he expressly allows over and over; as in page 2, 3, 28, 33, 73, and 95: and having
reason to look upon them as such, page 28. And towards the close of his book, he declares
himself stedfastly of the mind, that it is requisite those be not admitted to the Lord’s supper,
who do not make a personal and public profession of their faith and repentance, to the just
satisfaction of the church, page 93, 94. But how he reconciled these passages with the rest of
his Treatise, I would modestly say, I must confess myself at a loss. And particularly, I cannot
see how they consist with what this venerable and ever-honoured author says, page 16, in
these words; “Indeed by the rule that God has given for admissions, if it be carefully attended,
more unconverted persons will be admitted than converted.” I would humbly inquire, how
those visible qualifications can be the ground of a rational judgment, that a person is circum-
cised in heart, which nevertheless, at the same time, we are sensible are so far from being
any probable signs of it, that they are more frequently without it than with it. The appearance
of that thing surely cannot imply an appearing probability of another thing, which at the
same time we are sensible is most frequently, and so most probably, without that other thing.
Indeed I can easily see, how that may seem visible, and appear probable, to God’s people,
by reason of the imperfect and dark state they are in, and so may oblige their charity, which
yet is not real, and which would not appear at all probable to angels, who stand in a clearer
light. And the different degrees of light, in which God’s church stands, in different ages,
may make a difference in this respect. The church under the New Testament being favoured
by God with a vastly greater light in divine things, than the church under the Old Testament,
that might make some difference, as to the kind of profession of religion that is requisite,
under these different dispensations, in order to a visibility of holiness; also a proper visibility
may fail in the greater number in some extraordinary case, and in exempt circumstances.
But how those signs can be a ground of a rational judgment that a thing is, which, at that
very time, and under that degree of light we then have, we are sensible do oftener fail than
438
not, and this ordinarily, I own myself much at a loss. Surely nothing but appearing reason
is the ground of a rational judgment. And indeed it is impossible in the nature of things, to
form a judgment, which at that very time we think to be not only without, but against,
probability.
If it be said, that although persons do not profess that wherein sanctifying grace consists,
yet seeing they profess to believe the doctrines of the gospel, which God is wont to make use
of in order to sanctification, and are called the doctrine which is according to godliness; and
since we see nothing in their lives to make us determine, that they have not had a proper
effect on their hearts, we are obliged in charity to hope, that they are real saints, or gracious
1757
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.