10. If it is true that a man cannot receive the gospel without giving up everything, why
do you delude your followers, by allowing them to keep in your service their wives, and
children, and households, and houses, and fields? Indeed, you may well allow them to dis-
regard the precepts of the gospel: for all you promise them is not a resurrection, but a change
to another mortal existence, in which they shall live the silly, childish, impious life of those
you call the Elect, the life you live yourself, and are so much praised for; or if they possess
greater merit, they shall enter into melons or cucumbers, or some eatables which you will
masticate, that they may be quickly purified by your digestion. Least of all should you who
teach such doctrines profess any regard for the gospel. For if the faith of the gospel had any
connection with such nonsense, the Lord should have said, not, "I was hungry, and ye gave
167
me meat;" but, "Ye were hungry, and ye ate me," or, "I was hungry, and I ate you." For, by
your absurdities, a man will not be received into the kingdom of God for the service of giving
food to the saints, but, because he has eaten them and belched them out, or has himself been
eaten and belched into heaven. Instead of saying, "Lord, when saw we Thee hungry, and
fed Thee?" the righteous must say, "When saw we Thee hungry, and were eaten by Thee?"
And He must answer, not, "When ye gave food to one of the least of these my brethren, you
gave to me;" but, "When you were eaten by one of the least of these my brethren, you were
eaten by me."
11. Believing and teaching such monstrosities, and living accordingly, you yet have the
boldness to say that you obey the precepts of the gospel, and to decry the Catholic Church,
which includes many weak as well as strong, both of whom the Lord blesses, because both
according to their measure obey the precepts of the gospel and hope in its promises. The
blindness of hostility makes you see only the tares in our harvest: for you might easily see
wheat too, if you were willing that there should be any. But among you, those who are
pretended Manichæans are wicked, and those who are really Manichæans are silly. For
where the faith itself is false, he who hypocritically professes it acts deceitfully, while he who
truly believes is deceived. Such a faith cannot produce a good life, for every man’s life is
good or bad according as his heart is engaged. If your affections were set upon spiritual
and intellectual good, instead of material forms, you would not pay homage to the material
sun as a divine substance, and as the light of wisdom, which every one knows you do, though
I now only mention it in passing.
————————————
283
Faustus claims that the Manichæans and not the Catholics are consistent…