CHAP. VIII.] BLESSEDNESS IMPOSSIBLE WITHOUTIMMORTALITY. 321
That this is aptly said, who denies ? But it is advice given
to the miserable man, that he may not be more miserable.
And it is not rightly or truly said to the blessed man, such
as all wish themselves to be, That cannot be which you will.
For if he is blessed, whatever he wills can be ; since he does
not will that which cannot be. But such a life is not for
this mortal state, neither will it come to pass unless when
immortality also shall come to pass. And if this could not
be given at all to man, blessedness too would be sought in
vain, since it cannot be without immortality.
Chap. viii.—Blessedness cannot exist without immortality.
11. As, therefore, all men will to be blessed, certainly, if
they will truly, they will also to be immortal ; for otherwise
they could not be blessed. And further, if questioned also
concerning immortality, as before concerning blessedness, all
reply that they will it. But blessedness of what quality
soever, such as is not so, but rather is so called, is sought, nay
indeed is feigned in this life, whilst immortality is despaired
of, without which true blessedness cannot be. Since he lives
blessedly, as we have already said before, and have sufficiently
proved and concluded, who lives as he wills, and wills nothing
wrongly. But no one wrongly wills immortality, if human
nature is by God's gift capable of it ; and if it is not capable
of it, it is not capable of blessedness. For, that a man may
live blessedly, he must needs live. And if life quits him by
his dying, how can a blessed life remain with him ? And
when it quits him, without doubt it either quits him un-
willing, or willing, or neither. If unwilling, how is the life
blessed which is so within his will as not to be within his
power ? And whereas no one is blessed who wills something
that he does not have, how much less is he blessed who is
quitted against his will, not by honour, nor by possessions, nor
by any other thing, but by the blessed life itself, since he will
have no life at all ? And hence, although no feeling is left
for his life to be thereby miserable (for the blessed life quits
him, because life altogether quits him), yet he is wretched as
long as he feels, because he knows that against his will that
is being destroyed for the sake of which he loves all else, and
DE TRIN. X