Van Espen.
Both the Canon and the Civil Law require the accusers to submit themselves to the law
of retaliation (lex talionis). Vide Gratian, Pt. II., Causa II., Quæst. III., 2 and 3, where we
read from the decree of Pope Hadrian; “Whoever shall not prove what he advances, shall
himself suffer the penalty due the crime he charged.” And under the name of Damasus,
“The calumniator, if he fail in proving his accusation, shall receive his tale.” The Civil Law
is in L. x., Cod. de Calumniatoribus, and reads, “Whoso charges a crime, shall not have licence
to lie with impunity, since justice requires that calumniators shall endure the punishment
due the crime which they failed to prove.”
The Council wishes that all accusations of bishops for ecclesiastical offences shall be
kept out of the secular courts, and shall be heard by synods of bishops, in the manner and
form here prescribed, which is in accordance with the Constitution which under the names
of Valens, Gratian, and Valentinian, the Emperors, is referred to in law xxiij. of the Code
of Theodosius, De Episcopis et Clericis.
Whatever may be said of the meeting of bishops at which this canon was enacted, this
is clear, no mention was made of the Roman Pontiff, nor of the Council of Sardica, as Fleury
notes in his Histoire Ecclesiastique, Lib. xviij., n. 8. From this it is evident either that at that
time the Orientals did not admit, especially for bishops, appeals to the Roman Pontiff; nor
did they accept the authority of the Synod of Sardica, in so far as it permitted that the sentence
given in a provincial synod, should be reopened by the neighbouring bishops together with
the bishops of the province, and if it seemed good, that the cause might be referred to Rome.
361
Canon VI.