SECT. XII.
Of a supposed tendency of these principles to Atheism and Licentiousness.
If any object against what has been maintained, that it tends to Atheism; I know not on
what grounds such an objection can be raised, unless it be, that some Atheists have held a
doctrine of necessity which they suppose to be like this. But if it be so, I am persuaded the
Arminians would not look upon it just, that their notion of freedom and contingence should
be charged with a tendency to all the errors that ever any embraced, who have held such
opinions. The Stoic philosophers, whom the Calvinists are charged with agreeing with, were
no Atheists, but the greatest Theists, and nearest akin to Christians in their opinions con-
cerning the unity and the perfections of the Godhead, of all the heathen philosophers. And
Epicurus, that chief father of Atheism, maintained no such doctrine of necessity, but was
the greatest maintainer of contingence.
The doctrine of necessity, which supposes a necessary connexion of all events, on some
antecedent ground and reason of their existence, is the only medium we have to prove the
being of God. And the contrary doctrine of contingence, even as maintained by Arminians,
(which certainly implies, or infers, that events may come into existence, or begin to be,
without dependence on any thing foregoing, as their cause, ground, or reason,) takes away
all proof of the being of God; which proof is summarily expressed by the apostle, in Rom.
i. 20. And this is a tendency to Atheism with a witness. So that, indeed, it is the doctrine of
Arminians, and not of the Calvinists, that is justly charged with a tendency to Atheism; it
being built on a foundation that is the utter subversion of every demonstrative argument
for the proof of a Deity; as has been shown, Part II. Sect. III.
And whereas it has often been said, that the Calvinistic doctrine of necessity saps the
foundations of all religion and virtue, and tends to the greatest licentiousness of practice:
this objection is built on the pretence, that our doctrine renders vain all means and endeav-
ours, in order to be virtuous and religious. Which pretence has been already particularly
considered in the 6th section of this Part; where it has been demonstrated, that this doctrine
has no such tendency; but that such a tendency is truly to be charged on the contrary doctrine:
inasmuch as the notion of contingence, which their doctrine implies, in its certain con-
sequences, overthrows all connexion in every degree, between endeavour and event, means
and end.
And besides, if many other things, which have been observed to belong to the Arminian
doctrine, or to be plain consequences of it, be considered, there will appear just reason to
suppose, that it is that which must rather tend to licentiousness. Their doctrine excuses all
evil inclinations, which men find to be natural; because, in such inclinations, they are not
self-determined, as such inclinations are not owing to any choice or determination of their
own Wills. Which leads men wholly to justify themselves in all their wicked actions, so far
as natural inclination has had a hand in determining their Wills to the commission of them.
SECTION XII. Of a supposed tendency of these principles to Atheism and Licentiousness.
752
SECTION XII. Of a supposed tendency of these principles to Atheism and…