THEODORET.
narrative, but, inaismuch as Theodoret was condemned in his absence we are concerned
here less with the manner in which his condemnation was brought about than with the
steps lie took to protest against and to reverse it.
To the prisoner of Cyrus courier after cornier would bring intelligence of the riots
and ti-icks of the council. At last came news of the crowning wrong. On the indictment
of an Antlochene presbyter named Pelagius, Theodoret was condemned as an enemy of
God, a disseminator of poison, a false teacher deserving to be burnt. In support of the
accusation was quoted the careful theological statement addressed by Theod'^ret to the monks in the Euphratensis and the Osrhoene which appears as Letter CLI., as well as
citations from his works at large. Dioscorus described the absent defendant as a blasphe-
mous enemy of God and the Emperor whose life had been spent in damning souls. The- odoret was sentenced not merely to deposition from his see but to degradation from the
priesthood and to excommunication, and his books were ordered to be burnt.' So the great council ended with the deposition of Flavian of Constantinople, Eusebius of Doryla^um,
Daniel of Carra;, Irenseus of Tyre, Aquilinus of Biblus, and Domnus of Antioch as well as
of Theodoret." Eutyches the heretic Archimandrite was restored and the brutal Dioscorus seemed master of Christendom. One word of manly Latin had broken in on the supple
suffrages of the servile orientals, the ^'■Contradlcittir" of Hilarius the representative of the Church of Rome.
To that church, and to its illustrious bishop, Theodoret naturally turned in his hour of
need. He implored his friend Anatolius to get him permission to plead his own cause in
person in the West, or if not to let him retire to his old home at Nicerte.^ The latter alter- native was conceded. In this retreat he received many proofs of the affectionate regard of
his friends and offers of more practical help than his modest necessities demanded.*
Thence products of his facile pen travelled far and wide. The whole series of letters writ-
ten at this period gives touching testimony to the gentle and forgiving spirit of the sorely
tried bishop. There is nothing of the bitterness and fierce anger which appear sometimes
in the earlier controversy with Cyril. He is refined, not soured, by adversity, and, though
he never approached nearer to canonization than the acquisition of the inferior title of
Blessed, he appears in these dark days as no unv/orthy specimen of the suffering saint.* The chief interest of these letters is in truth moral spiritual and theological. This, however,
has been obscured by the ecclesiastical interest which has been given them by the unwar-
ranted attempt to represent Theodoret's letter to Leo as an " appeal " to the see of Rome in the later and technical sense of the word. Whether St. Hilary of Aries ever did or did
not give the lie to his short life of strenuous protest against the growing aggrandizement of
the see of Rome, there is no doubt that before his death at the age of 41 in 449 his sufliagans
had been released by Leo from allegiance to a Metropolitan disobedient to the Roman
chair, and that Valentlnian had issued an edict confirming Leo's claims and making die
antagonist host in a battle, not as the shepherds of their people," Hist. Gketchcs, p. -(jj.) And it must tc conceded that s.0 far as outward circumstances went the Latrocinium was as eood a council as any other. As is [)ointe(i out by Dean Mihnan,
** It is difficult to discover in what respect, either in the legality of its convocation or the number and dignity of the assembled prelates, consists its inferiority to more received and honoured councils. Two imperial commissioners attended to maintain
order in the council and peace in the city. Dioscorus the patriarch of Alexandria by the Imperiiil command assumed the
presidency. The Bishops who formed the Synod of Constantinople were excluded as parties in the transaction, but Flavianus
took his place with the Metropolitans of Antioch and Jerusalem and no less than three hundred and sixty bishops and ecclesi- astics. Three ecclesiastics, Julian a bishop, Rcnatus a presbyter, and Hilarius a deacon were to represent the bishop of Rome.
The Abbot Barsumas (this was an innovation) took his seat \n theCouncil as a kind of representative of the monks." .Mil. man, Lat. Christ. Book II. Chap. iv. The fact is that the great Councils of the Early Church are like the great men of the
Early Church. Some have authority and some have not. But their authority does not depend upon formal circumstances or
outward position. They have authority because the inspired common sense of the Church has seen and valued the truth and
wisdom of their utterances. Athanasius, Arius, Cyril, and Nestorius, were all great churchmen. Alhanasius and Cyril stand out against the background of centuries as champions of the faith. Arius and Nestorius are counted as heretics.
Character does not outweigh doctrine. Nestorius is unsound in the faith though he was an amiable and virtuous man ; Cyril
is an authority of orthodoxy though his personal qualities were not saintly. Of all the councils that according to Ammianus
Marcellinus hamstrung the postal resources of the Empire, take Nicaja, Tyre, and the two Ephesian councils of ^31 and 'I49.
Nicxa and the earlier Ephesian are accepted by the Church Catholic. Tyre and the later Ephesian, though both were sum- moned at the will of princes and attended by a large concourse of bishops, are rejected. Why? The earlier Ephesian in the
disorder and violence of its proceedings was as disgraceful as theTyrian and the later Ephesian. The councils of Nic^a and
of Ephesus, called the first and the third ecumenical councils, are vindicated by the assent of the wisest of theChurch. The
dictum sernrHS Judical orhis terrarum here holds good, and is seen to be identical with the ultimate foundation of thecTeat
Aristotelian definition •' defined by reason, and as the wise man would define." And such is also the practical outcome of the statement of Article XXI. of the Church of England.
cf. the striking passage of Augustine (Cont. Maximin. Arian. ii. 14). " Sed unnc nee ego Ntccenum^ nee tit dehes Ariminense^tanguam prarjitdieatitrHSt^roferre consilium. Nee ego httjus auttoritate,nec tu ill ins detineris. Scrtpturarum auctoritntibuStnon guorumgHe propriiSfSed utrisque contmunibHH testibtis, res cum re, causa cum causa, ratio cum ratioue
coucerlet," On the first four accepted oecumenical councils Dr. Salmon ( lujallibility of the Clturcli, p. 2S7) remarks, " Ciregory
the Grea"". says that he venerates these four as the four Gospels, and describes them as the foursquare stones on which the structure of faith rests. Yet the hard struggle each of these councils had to make and the number of years which the struggle
lasted laefore its decrees obtained general acceptance, show that they obtain their authority because of the truth wliich they
declared and it was not because of their authority that the decrees were recognised as true." > Canon Venables Diet. Christ. Uiog. Acles du Brigandage, pp. 193, 195. 2 Evagrius i, 10.
» Ep. CXIX. * Ep. CXXIII. 6 Epp. CXIII. to CXXXIll. and CLXXXI.