24. The judges said: Tell us, O Manes, who designated the boundaries for the kingdom
of each, and who made the middle wall? For Archelaus begs that due importance be attached
to the practice of interrogation in this discussion. Manes said: The God who is good, and
who has nothing in common with evil, placed the firmament in the midst, in order to make
it plain1646 that the wicked one is an alien to Him. Archelaus said: How fearfully you belie
the dignity of that name! You do indeed call Him God, but you do so in name only, and
you make His deity resemble man’s infirmities. At one time out of the non-existent, and at
another time out of underlying matter, which indeed thus existed before Himself, you assert
that He did build the structure, as builders among men are wont to do. Sometimes also you
speak of Him as apprehensive, and sometimes as variable. It is, however, the part of God to
do what is proper to God, and it is the part of man to do what is proper to man. If, then,
God, as you say, has constructed a wall, this is a God who marks Himself out as apprehensive,
and as possessed of no fortitude. For we know that it is always the case that those who are
suspicious of the preparation of secret perils against them by strangers, and who are afraid
of the plots of enemies, are accustomed to surround their cities with walls, by which proced-
ure they at once secure themselves in their ignorance, and display their feeble capacity. But
here, too, we have something which ought not to be passed over by us in silence, but rather
brought prominently forward; so that even by the great abundance of our declarations on
the subject our adversary’s manifold craftiness may be brought to nought, with the help of
197
the truth on our side. We may grant, then, that the structure of the wall has been made with
the purpose of serving to distinguish between the two kingdoms; for without this one divi-
sion1647 it is impossible for either of them to have his own proper kingdom. But granting
this, then it follows further that in the same manner it will also be impossible for the wicked
one to pass without his own proper limits and invade the territories of the good King, inas-
much as the wall stands there as an obstacle, unless it should chance first to be cast down,
for we have heard that such things have been done by enemies, and indeed with our own
eyes we have quite recently seen an achievement of that nature successfully carried out.1648
And when a king attacks a citadel surrounded by a strong wall, he uses first of all the bal-
lista1649 and projectiles; then he endeavours to cut through the gates with axes, and to de-
molish the walls by the battering-rams; and when he at last obtains an entrance, and gains
1646 Reading “patefaceret” for the “partum faceret” of Codex Casinensis.
1647 The text gives sine hoc uno. But perhaps Routh is right in suggesting muro for uno = without this wall.
1648 Some suppose that Archelaus refers here to the taking of Charræ by the Persians in the time of Valerianus
Augustus, or to its recapture and restoration to the Roman power by the Eastern king Odenathus during the
empire of Gallienus.
1649 The ballista was a large engine fitted with cords somewhat like a bow, by which large masses of stone
and other missiles were hurled to a great distance.
Chapter XXIV.
461
Chapter XXIV.