Louvain in 1838;1144 but it is believed that no treatises of this series have ever before been
translated into English, nor are they separately edited. They are in themselves a valuable
authority for an important scene in the history of the Church, and afford a good example
both of the strength and the weakness of Augustin’s writing,—its strength, in the exhaustive
way in which he tears to pieces his opponent’s arguments, and the clearness with which he
exposes the fallacies of their reasoning; its weakness, in the persistency with which he pursues
a point long after its discussion might fairly have been closed, as though he hardly knew
when he had gained the victory; and his tendency to claim, by right of his position, a vantage-
ground which did not in reality belong to him till the superiority of his cause was proved.
J. R. King
Oxford, March, 1870.
1144 The other works bearing on this controversy are mentioned in the exhaustive volume of Ferd. Ribbeck,
Donatus und Augustinus (Elberfeld, 1858).—Ed.
693
Preface.