Chapter 20.—Refutation of the Absurd Idea of Two Territories.
22. But perhaps, instead of thus addressing carnal minds, we should rather descend to
the views of those who either dare not or are as yet unfit to turn from the consideration of
material things to the study of an immaterial and spiritual nature, and who thus are unable
to reflect upon their own power of reflection, so as to see how it forms a judgment of mater-
ial extension without itself possessing it. Let us descend then to these material ideas, and
let us ask in what direction, and on what border of the shining and sacred territory, to use
the expressions of Manichæus, was the region of darkness? For he speaks of one direction
and border, without saying which, whether the right or the left. In any case, it is clear that
to speak of one side implies that there is another. But where there are three or more sides,
either the figure is bounded in all directions, or if it extends infinitely in one direction, still
it must be limited in the directions where it has sides. If, then, on one side of the region of
light there was the race of darkness, what bounded it on the other side or sides? The
Manichæans say nothing in reply to this; but when pressed, they say that on the other sides
the region of light, as they call it, is infinite, that is, extends throughout boundless space.
They do not see, what is plain to the dullest understanding, that in that case there could be
no sides? For the sides are where it is bounded. What, then, he says, though there are no
sides? But what you said of one direction or side, implied of necessity the existence of an-
other direction and side, or other directions and sides. For if there was only one side, you
should have said, on the side, not on one side; as in reference to our body we say properly,
By one eye, because there is another; or on one breast, because there is another. But if we
spoke of a thing as being on one nose, or one navel, we should be ridiculed by learned and
unlearned, since there is only one. But I do not insist on words, for you may have used one
in the sense of the only one.
Refutation of the Absurd Idea of Two Territories.
231
Refutation of the Absurd Idea of Two Territories.