of visible saints are born in covenant; and being already in covenant, they must have a right
to the privileges of the covenant, without any more ado: such therefore have a right to come
to the Lows supper, whether they are truly godly or not.
But the show of argument there is here, depends on the ambiguity of the phrase, being
in covenant; which signifies two distinct things: either, (1.) Being under the obligation and
bond of the covenant; or, (2.) Being conformed to the covenant, and complying with the terms
of it. Being the subject of the obligations and engagements of the covenant, is a thing quite
distinct from being conformed to these obligations, and so being the subject of the conditions
of the covenant.
Now it is not being in covenant in the former, but the latter sense, that gives a right to
the privileges of the covenant. The reason is plain, because compliance and conformity to
the terms of a covenant, is the thing which gives right to all the benefits; and not merely
being under ties to that compliance and conformity. Privileges are not annexed merely to
obligations, but to compliance with obligations.
Many that do not so much as visibly comply with the conditions of the covenant, are
some of God’s covenant people in that sense, that they are under the bonds and engagements
of the covenant; so were Korah and his company; so were many gross idolaters in Israel,
that lived openly in that sin; and so may heretics, deists, and atheists be God’s covenant
people. They may still be held under the bonds of their covenant engagements to God; for
their great wickedness and apostacy does not free them from the obligation of the solemn
promises and engagements they formerly entered into. But yet being in covenant merely in
this sense, gives them no right to any privileges of the covenant. In order to that, they must
be in covenant in another sense; they must cordially consent to the covenant; which indeed
Mr. W. himself owns, when he acknowledges, that in order to come to sacraments, men
525
must profess a cordial consent to, and compliance with the conditions of the covenant of
grace. 422 And if Mr. W. inquires, Why those children that were born in the covenant, are
not cast out, when in adult age they make no such profession; certainly, it as much concerns
him to answer, as me; for it is as much his doctrine, as mine, that they must profess such
consent.—But I am willing to answer nevertheless.—They are not cast out, because it is a
matter held in suspense, whether they do cordially consent to the covenant, or not; or
whether their making no such profession do not arise from some other cause. And none
are to be excommunicated, without some positive evidence against them. And therefore
422 If it be said here, those who have been born of baptized ancestors, though they do not comply with the
terms of the covenant, are in covenant, in this sense, that they have a right to the promises of the covenant
conditionally, in case they will hereafter comply: I answer, So are all mankind in covenant, God may be said to
have bound himself to them all conditionally; and many have these promises declared to them, that still remain
Jews, Mahometans, or heathens.
2016
SECTION XIV. Of being born in covenant.