230
from our God, or to break any of the commandments. And chief among these is Manichæus
himself; for the truth of the law and the prophets convinces him of error as trying to turn
us away from our God, the God of Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, whom Christ acknow-
ledges, and as trying to break the commandments of the law, which, even when they are
only figurative, we regard as prophetic of Christ.
26. Faustus uses an argument which is either very deceitful or very stupid. And as
Faustus is not stupid, it is probable that he used the argument intentionally, with the design
of misleading the careless reader. He says: If these things are not written of Christ, and if
you cannot show any others, it follows that there are none at all. The proposition is true;
but it remains to be proved, both that these things are not written of Christ, and that no
other can be shown. Faustus has not proved this; for we have shown both how these things
are to be understood of Christ, and that there are many other things which have no meaning
but as applied to Christ. So it does not follow, as Faustus says, that nothing was written by
Moses of Christ. Let us repeat Faustus’ argument: If these things are not written of Christ,
and if you cannot show any others, it follows that there are none at all. Perfectly so. But as
both these things and many others have been shown to be written of Christ, or with reference
to Christ, the true conclusion is that Faustus’ argument is worthless. In the passages quoted
by Faustus, he has tried, though without success, to show that they were not written of
Christ. But in order to draw the conclusion that there are none at all, he should first have
proved that no others can be shown. Instead of this, he takes for granted that the readers
of his book will be blind, or the hearers deaf, so that the omission will be overlooked, and
runs on thus: If there are none, Christ could not have asserted that there were any. And if
Christ did not make this assertion, it follows that this verse is spurious. Here is a man who
thinks so much of what he says himself, that he does not consider the possibility of another
person saying the opposite. Where is your wit? Is this all you could say for a bad cause?
But if the badness of the cause made you utter folly, the bad cause was your own choice.
To prove your antecedent false, we have only to show some other things written of Christ.
If there are some, it will not be true that there are none. And if there are some, Christ may
have asserted that there were. And if Christ may have asserted this, it follows that this verse
of the Gospel is not spurious. Coming back, then, to Faustus’ proposition, If you cannot
show any other, it follows that there are none at all, it requires to be proved that we cannot
show any other. We need only refer to what we showed before, as sufficient to prove the
truth of the text in the Gospel, in which Christ says, "If ye believed Moses, ye would also
believe me; for he wrote of me." And even though from dullness of mind we could find
nothing written of Christ by Moses, still, so strong is the evidence in support of the authority
of the Gospel, that it would be incumbent on us to believe that not only some things, but
everything written by Moses, refers to Christ; for He says not, He wrote also of me, but, He
wrote of me. The truth then is this, that even though there were doubts, which God forbid,
392
Faustus willing to believe not only that the Jewish but that all Gentile…