as, before the Roman Empire became Christian, the Apostle Paul took measures to secure
that the protection of armed Roman soldiers should be granted him against the Jews who
had conspired to kill him. But these emperors, whatever the occasion of their becoming
acquainted with the crime of your schism might be, frame against you such decrees as their
zeal and their office demand. For they bear not the sword in vain; they are the ministers of
God to execute wrath upon those that do evil. Finally, if some of our party transgress the
bounds of Christian moderation in this matter, it displeases us; nevertheless, we do not on
their account forsake the Catholic Church because we are unable to separate the wheat from
the chaff before the final winnowing, especially since you yourselves have not forsaken the
Donatist party on account of Optatus, when you had not courage to excommunicate him
for his crimes.
9. You say, however, “Why seek to have us joined to you, if we be thus stained with
guilt?” I reply: Because you still live, and may, if you are willing, be restored. For when you
join yourselves to us, i.e. to the Church of God, the heritage of Christ, who has the ends of
the earth as his possession, you are restored so that you live in vital union with the Root.
For the apostle says of the branches which were broken off: “God is able to graft them in
again.”2096 We exhort you to change, in so far as concerns your dissent from the Church;
although, as to the sacraments which you had, we admit that they are holy, since they are
the same in all. Wherefore we desire to see you changed from your obstinacy, that is, in order
that you who have been cut off may be vitally united to the Root again. For the sacraments
which you have not changed are approved by us as you have them; else, in our attempting
to correct your sin, we should do impious wrong to those mysteries of Christ which have
not been deprived of their worth by your unworthiness. For even Saul did not, with all his
sins, destroy the efficacy of the anointing which he received; to which anointing David, that
pious servant of God, showed so great respect. We therefore do not insist upon rebaptizing
you, because we only wish to restore to you connection with the Root: the form of the branch
which has been cut off we accept with approval, if it has not been changed; but the branch,
however perfect in its form, cannot bear fruit, except it be united to the root. As to the per-
secution, so gentle and tempered with clemency, which you say you suffer at the hands of
our party, while unquestionably your own party inflict greater harm in a lawless and irreg-
ular way upon us,—this is one question: the question concerning baptism is wholly distinct
from it; in regard to it, we inquire not where it is, but where it profits. For wherever it is, it
is the same; but it cannot be said of him who receives it, that wherever he is, he is the same.
We therefore detest the impiety of which men as individuals are guilty in a state of schism;
but we venerate everywhere the baptism of Christ. If deserters carry with them the imperial
standards, these standards are welcomed back again as they were, if they have remained
2096 Rom. xi. 23.
820
To Emeritus