ST. ANDREWS IN SCOTTISH UNIVERSITY SYSTEM
During his youth he was lavish in giving presents to all
who came in contact with him, especially to servants, pipers,
the boy who wrote notes for him on his class work, and to
men in similar positions, and there is no doubt that he was
naturally kind and generous. The careers of the two leaders
were very different. Argyll in a striking degree gained the
confidence of the Scottish people, was shrewd and wise in his
counsels, and steered his way through the enormous difficulties
which the perplexities of the situation caused in such a manner
as to deserve high praise. Naturally, as all men in similar
situations have had to experience, he was blamed for tortuous
ways and infidelity to his party, but there was no real foundation
for such accusations. He often kept his own counsel, and
did not reveal to any one his motives ; but there is nothing
to indicate that he was anything but a straightforward, honest
man, deeply religious and true to the Covenant. His difficulties
with the King were great. He believed to the end that the
King must carry out the principles of the Covenant and did
his best to persuade him to do so, actually crowned him when
the King was in Scotland, and professed affection for him ;
but the King did not take to him, and when he came to the
throne at the Restoration, Argyll was executed. Montrose
also accepted the Covenant, and at an early period he may
have been drawn by the universal enthusiasm of the people
into something like religious fervour, but it is plain that he
never felt deeply the religious motive. He was probably
somewhat indifferent to forms of Church government, but
he also had the strong Scotch persuasion that the monarch
should be a constitutional monarch. He had the feeling that
if the King were to trust him he could bring all parties into
peace with each other, and that the King might have a happy
reign if he adopted constitutional principles. He was eager
to get his hand into the management of the army, or into
23