THE DIALOGUE AGAINST THE LUCIFERIANS.
329
the Son of God is co-eternal with the Father,
let him be anathema." There was again a
chorus of approval, "Let htm be anathema."
" If anyone says that the Son of God is a creature, like other creatures, let him be
anathema." The answer was the same, " Let
him be anathema." " If anyone says that the Son was of no existing things, yet not of
God the Father, let him be anathema." All
shouted together, ''Let him be anathema."
" If anyone says, There was a time when the
Son was not, let him be anathema." At this point all the bishops and the whole Church
together received the words of Valens with
clapping of hands and stamping of feet. And
if anyone thinks we have invented the story
let him examine the public records. At all
events the muniment-boxes of the Churches
are full of it, and the circumstance is fresh in
men's memory. Some of those who took part in the Synod are still alive, and the Arians
themselves (a fact which may put the truth
beyond dispute) do not deny the accuracy of
our account. When, therefore, all extolled
Valens to the sky and penitently condemned
themselves for having suspected him, the same
Claudius who before had begun to read, said
" There are still a few points which have escaped the notice of my lord and brother
Valens ; if it seem good to you, let us, in
order to remove all scruples, pass a general
vote of censure upon them. If anyone says that the Son of God was indeed before all
worlds but was by no means before all time,
so that he puts some thing before Him, let him
be anathema." And many other things which had a suspicious look were condemned by
Valens when Claudius recited them. If any- one wishes to learn more about them he will
find the account in the acts of the Synod of
Ariminum, the source from which I have my- self drawn them.
19. After these proceedings the Council was
dissolved. All returned in gladness to their
own provinces. For the Emperor and all
good men had one and the same aim, that the
East and West should be knit together by the
bond of fellowship. But wickedness does not
long lie hid, and the sore that is healed super-
ficially before the bad humour has been
worked off breaks out again. Valens and
1 Ursacius and others associated with them in
their wickedness, eminent Christian bishops of
course, began to wave their palms, and to say
they had not denied that He was a creature,
but that He was like other creatures. At that
moment the term Usia was abolished : the
1 Bishop of Singedunum (Belgrade). " He and Valens. bishop of Mursa in Pannonia) appear at every Synod and Council from
330 till about »7p, as leaders of the Arian party, both in the East and West . . . They are described by Athanasius as the disciples
of Arius." Diet, of Chris. Biog.
Nicene Faith stood condemned by acclama-
tion. The whole world groaned, and was as- tonished to find itself Arian. Some, therefore,
remained in their own communion, others
began to send letters to those Confessors who
as adherents of Athanasius were in exile ;
several despairingly bewailed the better rela- tions into which they had entered. But a few,
true to human nature, defended their mistake
as an exhibition of wisdom. The ship of the
Apostles was in peril, she was driven by the
wind, her sides beaten with the waves : no hope
was now left. But the Lord awoke and bade
the tempest cease ; the ' beast died, and there was a calm once again. To speak more
plainly, all the bishops who had been banished
from their sees, by the clemency of the new
• emperor returned to their Churches. Then
Egypt welcomed the * triumphant Athanasius ;
then 4 Hilary returned from the battle to the
embrace of the Church of Gaul ; then * Eu-
sebius returned and Italy laid aside her mourn-
ing weeds. The bishops who had been caught
in the snare at Ariminum and had unwittingly
come to be reported of as heretics, began to
assemble, while they called the Body of our
Lord and all that is holy in the Church to
witness that they had not a suspicion of any-
thing faulty in their own faith. We thought,
said they, the words were to be taken in their
natural meaning, and we had no suspicion that
in the Church of God, the very home of sim-
plicity and sincerity in the confession of truth,
one thing could be kept secret in the heart,
another uttered by the lips. We thought too well of bad men and were deceived. We did
not suppose that the bishops of Christ were fight-
ing against Christ. There was much besides
which they said with tears, but I pass it over
for brevity's sake. They were ready to con-
demn their" former subscription as well as all the blasphemies of the Arians. Here I ask
our excessively scrupulous friends what they
think ought to have been done with those who
made this Confession ? Deprive the old bish-
ops, they will say, and ordain new ones. The
plan was tried. But how many whose con- science does not condemn them will allow
themselves to be deprived. Particularly when
all the people who loved their bishops flocked
together, ready to stone and slay those who
attempted to deprive them. The bishops
should, it may be said, have kept to themselves
1 Constantius. * Julian.
3 In August 362, " All Egypt seemed to assemble in the city (Alexandria), which blazed with lights and rang with acclama
tions ; the air was fragrant with incense burnt in token of joy ;
men formed a choir to precede the Archbishop ; to hear his
voice, to catch a glimpse of his face, even to see his shadow, was
deemed happiness." Bright, p. 115.
< Bishop of Poictiers (A. D. 350). Died A. D. 368.
6 Bishop of Vercellae in N. Italy. Died about A. D. 370. Both he and Hilary had been sent into exile by Constantius for their
opposition to Arian ism. • That is, the creed of Ariminum.