On Bk. VI. chap. 8, § 5 (note 4). Origen and Demetrius.
The friendship of Demetrius for Origen began early and continued, apparently without
interruption, for many years. In 203 he committed to him the charge of the catechetical
school (chap. 3); in the present chapter we find him encouraging him after learning of his
rash deed; some years afterward, upon Origen’s return from a visit to Rome, where his fame
as a teacher had already become very great, Demetrius still showed the very best spirit toward
him (chap. 14); and a little later sent him into Arabia to give instruction to an officer in that
country (chap. 19). It is soon after this that the first sign of a difference between the two
men appears, upon the occasion of Origen’s preaching in Cæsarea (ibid.). There seems,
however, to have been no lasting quarrel, if there was any quarrel at all; for in 231 we find
Demetrius giving Origen letters of recommendation upon the occasion of his visit to Achaia
(see below, p. 396). The fact that he gives him these letters, thus recognizing him as a
member of his church in good standing, and sending him upon his important mission with
his official approval, shows that no open break between himself and Origen can as yet have
taken place. But in his commentary on John (Tom. VI. præf.) Origen shows us that his last
years in Alexandria were by no means pleasant ones. He compares his troubles there to the
waves of a stormy sea, and his final departure to the exodus of the children of Israel. We
know that he had been engaged for some time in writing commentaries, and that the first
five books of his commentary on John—epoch-making in their significance, and sure to
cause a sensation in orthodox, conservative circles—had recently appeared. We know that
his reputation for heterodoxy was already quite widespread and that the majority of the
Egyptian clergy were by no means upon his side. The trials to which he refers, therefore,
may well have been a result of this hostility to his teachings existing among the clergy about
him, and Demetrius may have shared to an extent in the common feeling. At the same time
his disapproval cannot have been very pronounced, or he could not have given his official
sanction to Origen’s important visit to Achaia. But now, things being in this condition,
Origen set out upon his mission, leaving Heraclas in charge of his school, and undoubtedly
with the expectation of returning again, for he left the unfinished sixth book of his comment-
ary on John behind him (see preface to the sixth book). He stopped in Palestine on his way
to Athens, and there was ordained a presbyter by the bishops of that country (upon the
motives which prompted him in the matter, see below, p. 397). The result was a complete
break between Demetrius and himself, and his condemnation by an Alexandrian synod. To
understand Demetrius’ action in the matter, we must remember that both Eusebius and
395
Jerome attribute the change in his attitude to jealousy of Origen. They may be too harsh in
their judgment, and yet it is certainly not at all unnatural that the growing power and fame
of his young catechumen should in time affect, all unconsciously, his attitude toward him.
But we must not do Demetrius an injustice. There is no sign that his jealousy led him to attack
Origen, or to seek to undermine his influence, and we have no right to accuse him, without
On Bk. VI. chap. 8, § 5 (note 4). Origen and Demetrius.
1010
On Bk. VI. chap. 8, § 5 (note 4). Origen and Demetrius.