From the Same Second Book.
10. But if any quibbler, from the fact that I said that God is the Maker and Creator of
all things, thinks that I said that He is also Creator of Christ, let him observe that I first called
Him Father, in which word the Son also is at the same time expressed.730 For after I called
the Father the Creator, I added, Neither is He the Father of those things whereof He is
Creator, if He who begot is properly understood to be a Father (for we will consider the
latitude of this word Father in what follows). Nor is a maker a father, if it is only a framer
who is called a maker. For among the Greeks, they who are wise are said to be makers of
their books. The apostle also says, “a doer (scil. maker) of the law.”731 Moreover, of matters
of the heart, of which kind are virtue and vice, men are called doers (scil. makers); after
which manner God said, “I expected that it should make judgment, but it made iniquity.”732
11. That neither must this saying be thus blamed;733 for he says that he used the name
of Maker on account of the flesh which the Word had assumed, and which certainly was
made. But if any one should suspect that that had been said of the Word, even this also was
to be heard without contentiousness. For as I do not think that the Word was a thing made,
so I do not say that God was its Maker, but its Father. Yet still, if at any time, discoursing
of the Son, I may have casually said that God was His Maker, even this mode of speaking
would not be without defence. For the wise men among the Greeks call themselves the
makers of their books, although the same are fathers of their books. Moreover, divine
Scripture calls us makers of those motions which proceed from the heart, when it calls us
doers of the law of judgment and of justice.
730 Ibid., 4. 20.
731 Rom. ii. 13; James iv. 12. The Greek word ποιητής meaning either maker or doer, causes the ambiguity
here and below.
732 Isa. v. 7.
733 Athanasius adds (ut supra, 4. 21), that Dionysius gave various replies to those that blamed him for saying
that God is the Maker of Christ, whereby he cleared himself.
From the Same Second Book.
212
From the Same Second Book.