we must say that He was surrounded by darkness instead of Light, by falsehood instead of
truth, by death instead of life, by evil instead of good. For He Who creates, creates things
that are not; “That which is,” as Eunomius says, “needs not generation”; and of those things
which are considered as opposed, the better cannot be non-existent, except by the existence
of the worse. These are the gifts with which the wisdom of heresy honours the Father, by
which it degrades the eternity of the Son, and ascribes to God and the Father, before the
“production” of the Son, the whole catalogue of evils!
And let no one think to rebut by examples from the rest of creation the demonstration
of the doctrinal absurdity which results from this argument. One will perhaps say that, as,
when the sky was not, there was no opposite to it, so we are not absolutely compelled to
admit that if the Son, Who is Truth, had not come into existence, the opposite did exist. To
him we may reply that to the sky there is no corresponding opposite, unless one were to say
that its non-existence is opposed to its existence. But to virtue is certainly opposed that
which is vicious (and the Lord is virtue); so that when the sky was not, it does not follow
that anything was; but when good was not, its opposite was; thus he who says that good was
not, will certainly allow, even without intending it, that evil was. “But the Father also,” he
says922, “is absolute virtue, and life, and light unapproachable, and all that is exalted in word
219
or thought: so that there is no necessity to suppose, when the Only-begotten Light was not,
the existence of that darkness which is His corresponding opposite.” But this is just what I
say, that darkness never was; for the light never “was not,” for “the light,” as the prophecy
says, “is always in the light923.” If, however, according to the heretical doctrine, the “ungen-
erate light” is one thing, and the “generated light” another, and the one is eternal, while the
other comes into existence at a later time, it follows of absolute necessity that in the eternal
light we should find no place for the establishment of its opposite; (for if the light always
shines, the power of darkness has no place in it;) and that in the case of the light which
comes into being, as they say, afterwards, it is impossible that the light should shine forth
save out of darkness; and the interval of darkness between eternal light and that which arises
later will be clearly marked in every way.924 For there would have been no need of the
making of the later light, if that which was created had not been of utility for some purpose:
and the one use of light is that of the dispersion by its means of the prevailing gloom. Now
the light which exists without creation is what it is by nature by reason of itself; but the
created light clearly comes into being by reason of something else. It must be then that its
existence was preceded by darkness, on account of which the light was of necessity created,
922 The words are probably those of the imaginary objector; but they may be a citation from Eunomius.
923 The reference is probably to Ps. xxxvi. 9.
924 i.e.the “later light” must have arisen from darkness; therefore darkness must have intervened between
the “eternal light” and the “later light.”
419
Then, having shown that Eunomius' calumny against the great Basil, that…