51
Proposed Action on Clerical Celibacy.
[The Acts are not extant.]
Notes.
Often the mind of a deliberative assembly is as clearly shown by the propositions it rejects
as by those it adopts, and it would seem that this doctrine is of application in the case of the
asserted attempt at this Council to pass a decree forbidding the priesthood to live in the use
of marriage. This attempt is said to have failed. The particulars are as follows:
Hefele.
(Hist. Councils, Vol. I., pp. 435 et seqq.)
Socrates, Sozomen, and Gelasius affirm that the Synod of Nicæa, as well as that of Elvira
(can. 33), desired to pass a law respecting celibacy. This law was to forbid all bishops, priests
and deacons (Sozomen adds subdeacons), who were married at the time of their ordination,
to continue to live with their wives. But, say these historians, the law was opposed openly
and decidedly by Paphnutius, bishop of a city of the Upper Thebaïs in Egypt, a man of a
high reputation, who had lost an eye during the persecution under Maximian. He was also
celebrated for his miracles, and was held in so great respect by the Emperor, that the latter
often kissed the empty socket of the lost eye. Paphnutius declared with a loud voice, “that
too heavy a yoke ought not to be laid upon the clergy; that marriage and married intercourse
are of themselves honourable and undefiled; that the Church ought not to be injured by an
extreme severity, for all could not live in absolute continency: in this way (by not prohibiting
married intercourse) the virtue of the wife would be much more certainly preserved (viz.
the wife of a clergyman, because she might find injury elsewhere, if her husband withdrew
from her married intercourse). The intercourse of a man with his lawful wife may also be
a chaste intercourse. It would therefore be sufficient, according to the ancient tradition of
the Church, if those who had taken holy orders without being married were prohibited from
marrying afterwards; but those clergymen who had been married only once as laymen, were
not to be separated from their wives (Gelasius adds, or being only a reader or cantor).” This
discourse of Paphnutius made so much the more impression, because he had never lived
in matrimony himself, and had had no conjugal intercourse. Paphnutius, indeed, had been
brought up in a monastery, and his great purity of manners had rendered him especially
celebrated. Therefore the Council took the serious words of the Egyptian bishop into con-
sideration, stopped all discussion upon the law, and left to each cleric the responsibility of
deciding the point as he would.
If this account be true, we must conclude that a law was proposed to the Council of
Nicæa the same as one which had been carried twenty years previously at Elvira, in Spain;
this coincidence would lead us to believe that it was the Spaniard Hosius who proposed the
law respecting celibacy at Nicæa. The discourse ascribed to Paphnutius, and the consequent
decision of the Synod, agree very well with the text of the Apostolic Constitutions, and with
Proposed Action on Clerical Celibacy.
122
Proposed Action on Clerical Celibacy.