LXXXVI.
1788
To Flavianus, Bishop of Constantinople.
At the present time, most
God-beloved lord, I have received many buffetings of billows, but I
called upon the great Pilot, and have been able to stand firm against
the storm; the attacks, however, now made upon me transcend every story
in tragedy. In relation to the attacks which are being plotted against
the apostolic faith, I thought that I should find an ally and
fellow-worker in the most godly bishop of Alexandria, the lord
Dioscorus,
1789
and so sent him one of our pious
presbyters, a man of remarkable prudence, with a synodical letter
informing his piety that we abide in the agreement made in the time of
Cyril of blessed memory, and accept the letter written by him as well
as that written by the very blessed and sainted Athanasius to the
blessed Epictetus, and, before these, the exposition of the faith laid
down at Nicæa in Bithynia by the holy and blessed Fathers. We
exhorted him to induce those who are unwilling to abide by these
documents at once to abide by them. But one of the opposite party, who
keep up these disturbances, by tricking some of those who are on the
spot and contriving countless calumnies against myself has stirred an
iniquitous agitation against me.
But the very godly bishop
Dioscorus has written us a letter such as never ought to have been
written by one who has learnt from the God of all not to listen to vain
words. He has believed the charges brought against me as though he had
made personal enquiry into every one of them, and had arrived at the
truth after questioning, and has thus condemned me. I however have
bravely borne the calumnious charge, and have written him back a
courteous letter, representing to his piety that the whole charge
is
false,
and that not one of the godly bishops of the East holds opinions
contrary to the apostolic decrees. Moreover the pious clergy whom he
sent as messengers have been convinced by the actual evidence of the
facts. These however he has dismissed unheeded, and, lending his ears
to my calumniators, has acted in a manner quite incredible, were it not
that the whole church bears witness to it. He put up with them that
were crying Anathema against me; nay he stood up in his place and
confirmed their words by adding his voice to theirs. Besides all this
he sent certain godly bishops to the imperial city, as we learnt, in
the hope of increasing the agitation against me. I in the first place
have for champion Him who seeth all things, for it is on behalf of the
divine decrees that I am wrestling—next after Him I invoke your
holiness to fight in defence of the faith that is attacked, and do
battle on behalf of the canons that are being trodden under foot. When
the blessed Fathers were assembled in that imperial city
1790
in harmony with them that had sat in
council at Nicæa, they distinguished the dioceses, and assigned to
each diocese the management of its own affairs, expressly enjoining
that none should intrude from one diocese into another. They ordered
that the bishop of Alexandria should administer the government of Egypt
alone, and every diocese its own affairs.
1791
Dioscorus, however, refuses to
abide by these decisions; he is turning the see of the blessed Mark
upside down; and these things he does though he perfectly well knows
that the Antiochene metropolis possesses the throne of the great Peter,
who was teacher of the blessed Mark, and first and coryphæus of
the chorus of the apostles.
1792
But I know the majesty of the
see, and I know and take measure of myself. I have learnt from the
first the humility of the Apostles. I beseech your holiness not to
overlook the trampling underfoot of the holy canons, and to stand
forward zealously as champion of the divine faith, for in that faith we
have hope of our salvation and on its account are confident that we
shall meet with mercy.
But that your holiness may not
be ignorant of this, know, my lord, that he shewed his ill-will towards
me from the time of my assenting, in obedience to the canons of the
holy Fathers, to the synodical letters issued in your see in the time
of Proclus of blessed memory; on this point he has chidden me once and
again on the ground of my violating the rights of the church of Antioch
and, as he says, of that of Alexandria. Remembering this, and finding,
as he thinks, an opportunity, he has exhibited his hostility. But
nothing is stronger than the truth. Truth is wont to conquer even with
few words. I beseech your holiness to remember me in your prayers to
the Lord that I may have power to prevail against the waves that are
beating me hither and thither.
1788
This important letter may be placed between the sentence of
deposition issued by Dioscorus in Feb. 448 and the imperial edict of
March 449; probably before November 448, when Eutyches was arraigned
before the Synod of Constantinople presided over by Flavian.
1789
cf. Letter LX, written probably not long after the consecration of
Dioscorus in 444.
1790
i.e. in Constantinople in 381. The second Canon of the Council is
referred to,—confining each bishop to his own
“diocese,” i.e. a tract comprising more than one province.
So the bishop of Alexandria was restricted to Egypt.
1791
The immediate cause of this enactment by the Constantinopolitan
Fathers was the interference of Peter of Alexandria in the appointment
to the see of Constantinople, when the orthodox party nominated Gregory
of Nazianzus. cf. p. 136.
1792
The third Canon of Constantinople had enacted that henceforth the
see of the new capital should rank next after Rome. In the text the
precedence of Antioch before Alexandria is based on association with
St. Peter. “The so-called Cathedra Petri, which is kept in a
repository of the wall of the apse of the Vatican Basilica,” and
was “exhibited in 1866” “is probably a throne made
for or presented to Charles the Bold in 875.” Dict. Christ. Ant.
ii. 1960. For the connexion of St. Peter with Antioch see Routh Rell.
Sac. i. 179.