Chapter 17.—That Even Varro
Himself Pronounced His Own Opinions Regarding the Gods
Ambiguous.
And the same is true with respect
to all the rest, as is true with respect to those things which I
have mentioned for the sake of example. They do not explain them,
but rather involve them. They rush hither and thither, to this
side or to that, according as they are driven by the impulse of
erratic opinion; so that even Varro himself has chosen rather to
doubt concerning all things, than to affirm anything. For, having
written the first of the three last books concerning the certain
gods, and having commenced in the second of these to speak of the
uncertain gods, he says: “I ought not to be censured for having
stated in this book the doubtful opinions concerning the gods.
For he who, when he has read them, shall think that they both ought
to be, and can be, conclusively judged of, will do so himself.
For my own part, I can be more easily led to doubt the things which
I have written in the first book, than to attempt to reduce all the
things I shall write in this one to any orderly system.” Thus
he makes uncertain not only that book concerning the uncertain
gods, but also that other concerning the certain gods. Moreover,
in that third book concerning the select gods, after having
exhibited by anticipation as much of the natural theology as he
deemed necessary, and when about to commence to speak of the
vanities and lying insanities of the civil theology, where he was
not only without the guidance of the truth of things, but was also
pressed by the authority of tradition, he says: “I will write
in this book concerning the public gods of the Roman people, to
whom they have dedicated temples, and whom they have conspicuously
distinguished by many adornments; but, as Xenophon of Colophon
writes, I will state what I think, not what I am prepared to
maintain: it is for man to think those things, for God to know
them.”
It is not, then, an account of
things comprehended and most certainly believed which he promised,
when about to write those things which were instituted by men. He
only timidly promises an account of things which are but the
subject of doubtful opinion. Nor, indeed, was it possible for him
to affirm with the same certainty that Janus was the world, and
such like things; or to discover with the same certainty such
things as how Jupiter was the son of Saturn, while Saturn was made
subject to him as king:—he could, I say, neither affirm nor
discover such things with the same certainty with which he knew
such things as that the world existed, that the heavens and earth
existed, the heavens bright with stars, and the earth fertile
through seeds; or with the same perfect conviction with which he
believed that this universal mass of nature is governed and
administered by a certain invisible and mighty force.