Chapter. 3.—3. But in what Cyprian adds, saying, "Nor yet because men once have
erred must there be always error, since it rather befits wise and God-fearing men gladly and
unhesitatingly to follow truth, when it is clearly laid before their eyes, than obstinately and
persistently to fight for heretics against their brethren and their fellow-priests,"1473 he is
uttering the most perfect truth; and the man who resists the manifest truth is opposing
himself rather than his neighbors. But, so far as I can judge, it is perfectly clear and certain,
from the many arguments which I have already adduced, that the baptism of Christ cannot
be invalidated even by the perversity of heretics, when it is given or received among them.
But, granting that it is not yet certain, at any rate no one who has considered what has been
said, even from a hostile point of view, will assert that the question has been decided the
other way. Therefore we are not striving against manifest truth, but either, as I think, we
are striving in behalf of what is clearly true, or, at any rate, as those may hold who think that
the question has not yet been solved, we are seeking for the truth. And therefore, if the truth
be other than we think, yet we are receiving those baptized by heretics with the same honesty
of heart with which those received them whom, Cyprian supposed, in virtue of their cleaving
to the unity of the Church, to be capable of pardon. But if the baptism of Christ, as is indic-
ated by the many arguments used above, can retain its integrity amid any defect either of
life or faith, whether on the part of those who seem to be within, and yet do not belong to
the members of the one dove or on the part of those whose severance from her extends to
being openly without, then those who sought its repetition in those former days deserved
the same pardon for their charity in clinging to unity, which Cyprian thought that those
deserved for charity of the same kind whom he believed to have been admitted without
baptism. They therefore who, without any cause (since, as Cyprian himself shows, the bad
cannot hurt the good in the unity of the Church), have cut themselves off from the charity
which is shown in this unity, have lost all place of pardon, and whilst they would incur de-
struction by the very crime of schism, even though they did not rebaptize those who had
been baptized in the Catholic Church, of how bitter punishment are they deserving, who
are either endeavoring to give to the Catholics who have it what Cyprian affirms that they
465
themselves have not, or, as is clear from the facts of the case, are bringing as a charge against
the Catholic Church that she has not what even they themselves possess?
1473 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. 23.
Chapter 3
827
Chapter 3