In other words, by the Divine γεννησις is not meant an act but an eternal and unchangeable fact, in the Divine Essence. Arius. not admitting this, objected at the outset of the controversy to the phrase ‘always Father, always Son,’ Theod. H. E. i. 4. p. 749, and Eunomius argues that, ‘if the Son is co-eternal with the Father, the Father was never such in act, ἐνεργὸς, but was ἀργός.’ Cyril. Thesaur. v. p. 41. S. Cyril answers that ‘works,’ ἔργα, are made ἔξωθεν, ‘from without;’ but that our Lord, as S. Athanasius here says, is neither a ‘work’ nor ‘from without.’ And hence he says elsewhere that, while men are fathers first in posse then in act, God is δυνάμει τε καὶ ἐνεργεί& 139· πατήρ. Dial. 2. p. 458. (vid. supr. p. 65. note m). Victorinus in like manner, says, that God is potentia et actione Deus sed in æterna, Adv. Ar. i. p. 202; and he quotes S. Alexander, speaking apparently in answer to Arius, of a semper generans generatio. And Arius scoffs at ἀειγεννής and ἀγεννητογενής. Theod. Hist. i. 4. p. 749. And Origen had said, ὁ σωτὴρ ἀεὶ γεννᾶται. ap. Routh. Reliq. t. 4. p. 304 and S. Dionysius calls Him the Radiance, ἄναρχὸν καὶ ἀειγενές. Sent. Dion 15. S. Augustine too says, Semper gignit Pater, et semper nascitur Filius. Ep. 238. n. 4. Petav. de Trin. ii. 5. n. 7, quotes the following passage from Theodorus Abucara, ‘Since the Son’s generation does but signify His having His existence from the Father, which He has ever, therefore He is ever begotten. For it became Him, who is properly (κυρίως) the Son, ever to be deriving His existence from the Father, and not as we who derive its commencement only. In us generation is a way to existence; in the Son of God it denotes the existence itself; in Him it has not existence for its end, but it is itself an end, τέλος, and is perfect, τέλειον.’ Opusc 26.
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 5, Section 14, editorial note cite_note-4","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":[{"$text_sha256":"6400b9b8132ab03e834d799bf5a264e8085408e18ff90208806c74226ebc06a1"}],"source_library_url":"/library/f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa/#ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_5#cite_note-4","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"note":{"backlink_hrefs":["#cite_ref-4"],"body_html":{"$text_sha256":"0a008351962d34d3cc7580dff99a0b0a73df79d59b3142082800de417a798ed7"},"body_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[4]/span[2]","container_html":{"$text_sha256":"c17838cf304583c09aa0ec7a3eee78ebcc217af107a73d4e05309f44430788e0"},"container_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[4]","id":"cite_note-4"},"original_work_coordinate":{"actual_note_parent_coordinates":[{"chapter":5,"native_section_number":14,"original_parent_paragraph":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"5d2e2fb5d9fa84b5be27ebe4c6e8a7b49411cfc7b874ec2e7f8c9a10e012ed77"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"5d2e2fb5d9fa84b5be27ebe4c6e8a7b49411cfc7b874ec2e7f8c9a10e012ed77","original_node_id":"mwCg","source_id":"f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa.html","source_sha256":"ff967627949e7c3e28fb7b659ef7f9f2ec6782f7101a1264fd35a76189d5eeb3","text":{"$text_sha256":"6400b9b8132ab03e834d799bf5a264e8085408e18ff90208806c74226ebc06a1"},"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"},"source_paragraph_index":2}],"actual_original_chapter_number":5,"actual_original_discourse_number":1,"actual_original_letter_number":null,"chapter":5,"discourse":1,"letter":null,"native_section_number":14,"numbering_basis":"Literal original p headings and actual observed reading-body catalogue ancestry; URL ordinals never treated as native chapter/letter numbers","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"033d6661f8d0903df7f348ccc3bb110e47b42c1a5b2731f8d2f91d8e98a1bd95"},"original_heading_evidence":[{"discourse":1,"heading_source_id":"347c934f7cfb86dd3883","heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"source_html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_utf8_byte_end":49156,"source_utf8_byte_start":49127,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:347c934f7cfb86dd3883:p:2","original_discourse_heading":"Discourse I."},{"chapter":5,"heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"17479174ff596835cc938a38583bf058487809e6520e216529592e593de8fe0a"},"html_sha256":"17479174ff596835cc938a38583bf058487809e6520e216529592e593de8fe0a","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"4390e1e79df3321698a3cbd9c8bed49edccf0b032b0c545fd1418a10a3a28200"},"source_html_sha256":"4390e1e79df3321698a3cbd9c8bed49edccf0b032b0c545fd1418a10a3a28200","source_utf8_byte_end":50180,"source_utf8_byte_start":49099,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[1]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:p:1","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"033d6661f8d0903df7f348ccc3bb110e47b42c1a5b2731f8d2f91d8e98a1bd95"}}],"original_letter_heading":null,"original_reading_body_catalogue_memberships":[{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"0ae0f5b3efd49ee337686db93a32bbe4d368493ae986a0508ad4a66be8a4c439"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[5]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 5","modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"},{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"0ae0f5b3efd49ee337686db93a32bbe4d368493ae986a0508ad4a66be8a4c439"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[5]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 5","actual_original_UL_reading_body_catalogue":true,"modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"}],"original_section_range_heading":null,"owner_verified_section_label":"Discourse 1, Chapter 5, Section 14","private_original_node_id":"mw-reference-text-cite_note-4","source_paragraph_index":null,"unestablished_native_number_not_invented":false},"reference_proofs":[],"source_id":"f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa","source_library_context_witnesses":[{"html":{"$text_sha256":"5d2e2fb5d9fa84b5be27ebe4c6e8a7b49411cfc7b874ec2e7f8c9a10e012ed77"},"html_sha256":"5d2e2fb5d9fa84b5be27ebe4c6e8a7b49411cfc7b874ec2e7f8c9a10e012ed77","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"}],"source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"0a008351962d34d3cc7580dff99a0b0a73df79d59b3142082800de417a798ed7"},"html_sha256":"0a008351962d34d3cc7580dff99a0b0a73df79d59b3142082800de417a798ed7","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[4]/span[2]"},"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/original-source-records.jsonl","source_record_file_sha256":"4b06e30487b04ff6f328981a08c3956d99fc7f5284b0ab0c262ac0d82cfe56e0","source_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4","source_sha256":"ff967627949e7c3e28fb7b659ef7f9f2ec6782f7101a1264fd35a76189d5eeb3","text_sha256":"233b63c52c14179e6b83dbd8439b9b0a8835e538cc395787fa84e18ac83123eb","type":"whole-source-library-dom"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 5, Section 14, editorial note cite_note-4","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":["14. When these points are thus proved, their profaneness goes further. ‘If there never was, when the Son was not,’ say they, ‘but He is eternal, and coexists with the Father, you call Him no more the Father’s Son, but brother.’ O insensate and contentious! For if we said only that He was eternally with the Father, and not His Son, their pretended scruple would have some plausibility; but if, while we say that He is eternal, we also confess Him to be Son from the Father, how can He that is begotten be considered brother of Him who begets? And if our faith is in Father and Son, what brotherhood is there between them? and how can the Word be called brother of Him whose Word He is? This is not an objection of men really ignorant, for they comprehend how the truth lies; but it is a Jewish pretence, and that from those who, in Solomon’s words, ‘through desire separate themselves’ from the truth. For the Father and the Son were not generated from some pre-existing origin, that we may account Them brothers, but the Father is the Origin of the Son and begat Him; and the Father is Father, and not born the Son of any; and the Son is Son, and not brother. Further, if He is called the eternal offspring of the Father, He is rightly so called. For never was the essence of the Father imperfect, that what is proper to it should be added afterwards; nor, as man from man, has the Son been begotten, so as to be later than His Father’s existence, but He is God’s offspring, and as being proper Son of God, who is ever, He exists eternally. For, whereas it is proper to men to beget in time, from the imperfection of their nature, God’s offspring is eternal, for His nature is ever perfect. If then He is not a Son, but a work made out of nothing, they have but to prove it; and then they are at liberty, as if imagining about a creature, to cry out, ‘There was once when He was not;’ for things which are originated were not, and have come to be. But if He is Son, as the Father says, and the Scriptures proclaim, and ‘Son’ is nothing else than what is generated from the Father; and what is generated from the Father is His Word, and Wisdom, and Radiance; what is to be said but that, in maintaining ‘Once the Son was not,’ they rob God of His Word, like plunderers, and openly predicate of Him that He was once without His proper Word and Wisdom, and that the Light was once without radiance, and the Fountain was once barren and dry? For though they pretend alarm at the name of time, because of those who reproach them with it, and say, that He was before times, yet whereas they assign certain intervals, in which they imagine He was not, they are most irreligious still, as equally suggesting times, and imputing to God an absence of Reason."],"source_library_url":"/library/f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa/#ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_5#cite_note-4","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"proof_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/proof-records.jsonl","proof_file_sha256":"134f60e56c87c2ec4333e23b6a2d2bf46ade76d1e36ebaa8435bdf01633d4a58","proof_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:f73ab495c2c356e8e2fa:cite_note-4"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}