what we have already said, and declares that he is the Paraclete whose mission was presigni-
fied by Jesus. And by this assertion, in his ignorance perchance, he will make out Jesus
Himself to be a liar;1680 for thus He who once said that He would send the Paraclete no long
time after, will be proved only to have sent this person, if we accept the testimony which he
bears to himself, after an interval of three hundred years and more.1681 In the day of judg-
ment, then, what will those say to Jesus who have departed this life from that time on to the
present period? Will they not meet Him with words like these: “Do not punish us rigorously
if we have failed to do Thy works. For why, when Thou didst promise to send the Paraclete
under Tiberius Cæsar, to convince us of sin and of righteousness,1682 didst Thou send Him
only under Probus the Roman emperor, and didst leave us orphaned, not withstanding that
Thou didst say, ‘I will not leave you comfortless (orphaned),’1683 and after Thou hadst also
assured us that Thou wouldest send the Paraclete presently after Thy departure? What could
we orphans do, having no guardian? We have committed no fault; it is Thou that hast de-
ceived us.” But away with such a supposition in the case of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Saviour
of every soul.1684 For He did not confine Himself to mere promises;1685 but when He had
once said, “I go to my Father, and I send the Paraclete to you,”1686 straightway He sent (that
gift of the Paraclete), dividing and imparting the same to His disciples,—bestowing it,
however, in greater fulness upon Paul.1687
1680 The same sort of argument is employed against the Montanists by Theodorus of Heracleia on John’s
Gospel, ch. xiv. 17.
1681 It is remarked in Migne, that it is only in the heat of his contention that this statement is made by
Archelaus as to the date of the appearance of Manes; for from the death of Christ on to the time of this discussion
there are only some 249 years. [Is it not probable that here is a token of the spurious character of not a little of
this work?]
1682 John xvi. 8.
1683 John xiv. 18.
1684 Reading “sed absit hoc a Domino nostro Jesu Christo Salvatore omnis animæ,” instead of the codex’s
“sed absit hanc a Domino Jesu Christo Salvatore omne animæ.”
1685 If the reference, however, is to 2 Pet. iii. 9, as Routh suggests, it may rather be = He was not slack con-
cerning His promises. The text is, “non enim moratus est in promissionibus suis.” [A noteworthy reference to
the second Epistle of St. Peter. For, if this work be a mere romance, yet its undoubted antiquity makes it useful,
not only in this, but in many other critical matters.]
1686 John xiv. 12; xvi. 28.
1687 Reading “abundantius vero conferens Paulo,” instead of the corrupt text in the Codex Casinensis,
“abundantibus vero confitens Paulo.”
471
Chapter XXVII.