On Bk. VI. chap. 23, § 4 (note 6).
Origen’s Visit to
Achaia
.
Eusebius gives as the cause of
Origen’s visit to Greece simply “a pressing necessity in
connection with ecclesiastical affairs,” but Jerome (
de vir.
ill
. c. 54) tells us that it was on account of heresies which were
troubling the churches of Achaia (
propter ecclesias Achaiæ,
quæ pluribus hæresibus vexabantur
). Photius (
Cod
.
118) reports that Origen went to Athens without the
consent of Demetrius
(
χωρὶς
τῆς τοῦ
οἰκείου
γνώμης
ἐπισκόπου
), but this must be regarded as a mistake (caused perhaps by
his knowledge that it was Origen’s ordination, which took place
during this trip, that caused Demetrius’ anger; for Photius does
not say that this statement rests upon the authority of Pamphilus, but
prefaces his whole account with the words
ὁ τε
Π€μφιλος
μ€ρτυς καὶ
ἕτεροι
πλεῖστοι
), for Jerome (
de vir. ill.
c. 54) says that Origen went to
Athens by way of Palestine
sub testimonio ecclesiasticæ
epistolæ
, and in chap. 62 he says that Alexander, bishop of
Jerusalem wrote an epistle in which he stated that he had ordained
Origen
juxta testimonium Demetrii
. We must therefore assume that
Origen left Alexandria for Athens with Demetrius’ approval, and
with letters of recommendation from him. It is the common opinion that
Origen left Alexandria this time about 228
a.d.
, and after his visit in Achaia returned to
Alexandria, where he remained until excommunicated by the council
called by Demetrius. Upon searching the sources, however, I can find
absolutely no authority for the statement that he returned to
Alexandria after his visit to Achaia; in fact, that he did seems by
most scholars simply to be taken for granted without further
investigation. The opinion apparently rests upon the interpretation of
two passages, one in a report of the proceedings of the Alexandrian
synod taken by Photius from Pamphilus’
Apology
, the other
in the preface to the sixth book of Origen’s commentary on the
Gospel of John. In the former it is said that the synod voted to exile
Origen from Alexandria, and forbade him to reside or to teach there
(
ψηφίζεται
μεταστῆναι
μὲν ἀπὸ
᾽Αλεξανδρείας
τὸν
᾽Ωριγένην,
καὶ μήτε
διατρίβειν
ἐν αὐτῇ, μήτε
διδ€σκειν
). But certainly such a decree is far from proving that
Origen, at the time it was passed, was actually in Alexandria. It
simply shows that he still regarded that city as his residence, and was
supposed to be expecting to return to it after his visit was completed.
In the preface to the sixth book of his commentary on John’s
Gospel, he speaks of the troubles and trials which he had been enduring
in Alexandria before he finally left the city, and compares that
departure to the exodus of the children of Israel. But certainly it is
just as easy to refer these troubles to the time before his visit to
Achaia, a time when in all probability the early books of his
commentary on John, as well as others of his writings, had begun to
excite the hostility of the Alexandrian clergy, and thus made his
residence there uncomfortable. It is almost necessary to assume that
this hostility had arisen some time before the synods were held, in
order to account both for the hostility of the majority of the clergy,
which cannot have been so seriously aroused in an instant, and also for
the change in Demetrius’ attitude, which must have found a
partial cause in the already existing hostility of the clergy to
Origen, hostility which led them to urge him on to take decisive steps
against Origen when the fitting occasion for action came in the
ordination of the latter (see above, p. 395). The only arguments which,
so far as I am able to learn, have been or can be urged for
Origen’s return to Alexandria are thus shown to prove nothing. On
the other hand, it is a fact that Origen was ordained on his way to
Achaia, and then went on and did his business there, and it is
difficult to imagine that Demetrius and the Alexandrian church would
have waited so long before taking action in regard to this step, which
appeared to them so serious. More than that, Origen reports that he had
begun the sixth book of his commentary on John in Alexandria, but had
left it there, and therefore began it anew in Palestine. It is
difficult to imagine that his departure was so hasty that he could not
take even his
mss.
with him; but if he left
only for his visit to Achaia, expecting to return again, he would of
course leave his
mss.
behind him, and when his
temporary absence was changed by the synod into permanent exile, he
might not have been in a position, or might not have cared, to send
back for the unfinished work. Still further, it does not seem probable
that, if he were leaving Alexandria an exile under the condemnation of
the church, and in such haste as the leaving of his unfinished
commentary would imply, he should be in a position to entrust the care
of his catechetical school to his assistant Heraclas (as he is said in
chap. 26 to have done). That matter would rather have been taken out of
his hands by Demetrius and the rest of the clergy. But going away
merely on a visit, he would of course leave the school in
Heraclas’ charge, and after his condemnation the clergy might see
that Heraclas was the man for the place, and leave him undisturbed in
it. After having, upon the grounds mentioned, reached the conclusion,
shared so far as I knew by no one else, that it is at least unlikely
that Origen returned to Alexandria after his visit to Greece, I was
pleased to find my position strengthened by some chronological
considerations urged by Lipsius (
Chronologie d. röm. Bischöfe
, p. 195, note), who says that “we do not know whether
Origen ever returned to Alexandria after his ordination,” and who
seems to think it probable that he did not. He shows that Pontianus did
not become bishop of Rome until 230, and therefore, if Eusebius is
correct in putting Origen’s visit to Achaia in the time of
Pontianus’ episcopate, as he does in this passage, that visit
cannot have taken place before 230 (the commonly accepted date, which
rests upon a false chronology of Pontianus’ episcopate, is 228);
while
on
the other hand, according to chap. 26, Origen’s final departure
from Alexandria took place in the tenth year of Alexander’s reign
(231
a.d.
), shortly before Demetrius’
death, which occurred not later than 232 (see Bk. V. chap. 22, note 4).
Supposing, then, that Origen returned to Alexandria, we must assume his
journey to Palestine, his ordination there, his visit to Achaia and
settlement of the disputes there, his return to Alexandria, the
composition of at least some part of his commentary on John, the
calling of a synod, his condemnation and exile,—all within the
space of about a year. These chronological considerations certainly
increase the improbability of Origen’s return to Alexandria. (It
may be remarked that Redepenning, who accepts the commonly received
chronology, assigns two years to the Cæsarean and Achaian visit.)
Assuming, then, that this departure for Achaia is identical with that
mentioned in chap. 26, we put it in the year 231. It must have been (as
of course we should expect, for he stopped in Palestine only on his way
to Achaia) very soon after his departure that Origen’s ordination
took place; and the synod must have been called very soon after that
event (as we should likewise expect), for Demetrius died the following
year.
As to the cause of
Origen’s ordination, it is quite possible, as Redepenning
suggests, that when he went a second time to Palestine, his old
friends, the bishops of Cæsarea, of Jerusalem, and of other
cities, wished to hear him preach again, but that remembering the
reproof of the bishop Demetrius, called forth by his preaching on the
former occasion (see chap. 19), he refused, and that then the
Palestinian bishops, in order to obviate that difficulty, insisted on
ordaining him. It is not impossible that Origen, who seems never to
have been a stickler for the exact observance of minor ecclesiastical
rules and formalities, supposed that Demetrius, who had shown himself
friendly in the past, and not hostile to him because of his youthful
imprudence (see chap. 8), would concur willingly in an ordination
performed by such eminent bishops, and an ordination which would prove
of such assistance to Origen in the accomplishment of the work in
Achaia which he was undertaking with the approval of Demetrius himself,
even though the latter could not bring himself to violate what he
considered an ecclesiastical canon against the ordination of eunuchs.
We can thus best explain Origen’s consent to the step which, when
we consider his general character, it is difficult to suppose he would
have taken in conscious opposition to the will of his bishop. (On
Demetrius’ view of the matter, see above, p. 394 sq.) He was
ordained, according to Jerome’s
de vir. ill
. c. 54 (cf.
also chap. 8, above), by Theoctistus, bishop of Cæsarea, and
Alexander, bishop of Jerusalem, together with “the most
distinguished bishops of Palestine” (as Eusebius says in chap.
8).