discipline. It is abundantly clear that the fathers in council in Trullo thought the discipline
they were setting forth to be the original discipline of the Church in the matter, and the
discipline of the West an innovation, but that such was really the case seems far from certain.
Thomassinus treats this point with much learning, and I shall cite some of the authorities
he brings forward. Of these the most important is Epiphanius, who as a Greek would be
certain to give the tradition of the East, had there been any such tradition known in his
time. I give the three great passages.
“It is evident that those from the priesthood are chiefly taken from the order of virgins,
or if not from virgins, at least from monks; or if not from the order of monks, then they are
wont to be made priests who keep themselves from their wives, or who are widows after a
single marriage. But he that has been entangled by a second marriage is not admitted to
priesthood in the Church, even if he be continent from his wife, or be a widower. Anyone
of this sort is rejected from the grade of bishop, presbyter, deacon, or subdeacon. The order
of reader, however, can be chosen from all the orders these grades can be chosen from, that
is to say from virgins, monks, the continent, widowers, and they who are bound by honest
marriage. Moreover, if necessity so compel, even digamists may be lectors, for such is not
a priest, etc., etc.”350
“Christ taught us by an example that the priestly work and ornaments should be com-
municated to those who shall have preserved their continency after a single marriage, or
shall have persevered in virginity. And this the Apostles thereafter honestly and piously
decreed, through the ecclesiastical canon of the priesthood.”351
“Nay, moreover, he that still uses marriage, and begets children, even though the husband
of but one wife, is by no means admitted by the Church to the order of deacon, presbyter,
bishop, or subdeacon. But for all this, he who shall have kept himself from the commerce
367
of his one wife, or has been deprived of her, may be ordained, and this is most usually the
case in those places where the ecclesiastical canons are most accurately observed.”352
Nor is the weight of this evidence lessened, but much increased, by the acknowledgment
of the same father that in some places in his days the celibate life was not observed by such
priests as had wives, for he explains that such a state of things had come about “not from
following the authority of the canons, but through the neglect of men, which is wont at
certain periods to be the case.”353
The witness of the Western Fathers although so absolutely and indisputably clear is not
so conclusive as to the East, and yet one passage from St. Jerome should be quoted. “The
350 Epiph. Exposit. Fid. Cath., c. xxi.
351 Ibid. Hæresi. 48, n. 7.
352 Epiph. Hæresi, 59, n. 4.
353 Ibid. ut supra.
645
Excursus on the Marriage of the Clergy.