Adimantus, whom Faustus, in his attack on the Old Testament, praises as second only to
Manichæus, wishes us to understand; but when retired from the crowd, the Lord repeated
this still more plainly and pointedly to His disciples. Adimantus quotes this saying of our
Lord in opposition to the Old Testament, where the people are prohibited from eating some
animals which are pronounced unclean; and doubtless he was afraid that he should be asked
why, since he quotes a passage from the Gospel about man not being defiled by what enters
into his mouth and passes into his belly, and out into the draft, he yet considers not some
only, but all flesh unclean, and abstains from eating it. It is in order to escape from this
strait, when the plain truth is too much for his error, that he makes the Lord say this to the
crowd; as if the Lord were in the habit of speaking the truth only in small companies, while
He blurted out falsehoods in public. To speak of the Lord in this way is blasphemy. And
all who read the passage can see that the Lord said the same thing more plainly to His disciples
in private. Since Faustus praises Adimantus so much at the beginning of this book of his,
placing him next to Manichæus, let him say in a word whether it is true or false that a man
is not defiled by what enters into his mouth. If it is false, why does this great teacher Adi-
mantus quote it against the Old Testament? If it is true, why, in spite of this, do you believe
that eating any flesh will defile you? It is true, if you choose this explanation, that the apostle
does not say that all things are pure to heretics, but, "to the pure all things are pure." The
apostle also goes on to explain why all things are not pure to heretics: "To the impure and
unbelieving nothing is pure, but both their mind and conscience are defiled."358 So to the
Manichæans there is absolutely nothing pure; for they hold that the very substance or nature
of God not only may be, but has actually been defiled, and so defiled that it can never be
wholly restored and purified. What do they mean when they call animals unclean, and refrain
from eating them, when it is impossible for them to think anything, whether food or whatever
171
it may be, clean? According to them, vegetables too, fruits, all kinds of crops, the earth and
sky, are defiled by mixture with the race of darkness. Why do they not act up to their
opinions about other things as well as about animals? Why do they not abstain altogether,
and starve themselves to death, instead of persisting in their blasphemies? If they will not
repent and reform, this is evidently the best thing that they could do.
7. The saying of the apostle, that "to the pure all things are pure," and that "every creature
of God is good," is not opposed to the prohibitions of the Old Testament; and the explanation,
if they can understand it, is this. The apostle speaks of the natures of the things, while the
Old Testament calls some animals unclean, not in their nature, but symbolically, on account
of the prefigurative character of that dispensation. For instance, a pig and a lamb are both
clean in their nature, for every creature of God is good; but symbolically, a lamb is clean,
and a pig unclean. So the words wise and fool are both clean in their nature, as words
358 Tit. i. 15.
289
Faustus avows his disbelief in the Old Testament and his disregard of its…