were from the beginning eye witnesses and ministers of the word delivered unto him, all of
whom, as he says, he followed accurately from the first.613 The other book is the Acts of the
137
Apostles614 which he composed not from the accounts of others, but from what he had seen
himself.
8. And they say that Paul meant to refer to Luke’s Gospel wherever, as if speaking of
some gospel of his own, he used the words, “according to my Gospel.”615
and New Testament Introductions, and for a clear exhibition of the synoptical problem in general, see Schaff’s
Ch. Hist. I. p. 607 sqq. On Luke in particular, p. 648 sqq.
613 Luke i. 2, 3.
614 Traces of a knowledge of the Acts are found in the Apostolic Fathers, in Justin, and in Tatian, and before
the end of the second century the book occupied a place in the Canon undisputed except by heretics, such as
the Marcionites, Manicheans, &c. The Muratorian Fragment and Irenæus (III. 14) are the first to mention Luke
as the author of the Acts, but from that time on tradition has been unanimous in ascribing it to him. The only
exception occurs in the case of Photius (ad Amphil. Quæst. 123, ed. Migne), who states that the work was ascribed
by some to Clement, by others to Barnabas, and by others to Luke; but it is probable as Weiss remarks that
Photius, in this case, confuses the Acts with the Epistle to the Hebrews. As to the date of its composition. Irenæus
(III. 1. 1) seems (one cannot speak with certainty, as some have done) to put it after the death of Peter and Paul,
and therefore, necessarily, the Acts still later. The Muratorian Fragment implies that the work was written at
least after the death of Peter. Later, however, the tradition arose that the work was written during the lifetime
of Paul (so Jerome, de vir. ill. 7), and this has been the prevailing opinion among conservative scholars ever
since, although many put the composition between the death of Paul and the destruction of Jerusalem; while
some (e.g. Weiss) put it after the destruction of Jerusalem, though still assigning it to Luke. The opposite school
of critics deny Luke’s authorship, throwing the book into the latter part of the first century (Scholten, Hilgenfeld,
&c.), or into the times of Trajan and Hadrian (e.g. Volkmar, Keim, Hausrath, &c.). The Tübingen School saw
in the Acts a “tendency-writing,” in which the history was intentionally perverted. This theory finds few supporters
at present, even among the most extreme critics, all of whom, however, consider the book a source of the second
rank, containing much that is legendary and distorted and irreconcilable with Paul’s Epistles, which are looked
upon as the only reliable source. The question turns upon the relation of the author of the “we” sections to the
editor of the whole. Conservative scholars agree with universal tradition in identifying them (though this is not
necessary in order to maintain the historical accuracy of the work), while the opposite school denies the identity,
considering the “we” sections authentic historical accounts from the pen of a companion of Paul, which were
afterward incorporated into a larger work by one who was not a pupil of Paul. The identity of the author of the
third Gospel and of the Acts is now admitted by all parties. See the various Commentaries and New Testament
Introductions; and upon the sources of the Acts, compare especially Weizsäcker’s Apost. Zeitalter, p. 182 sqq.,
and Weiss’ Einleitung, p. 569 sq.
615 Rom. ii. 16, xvi. 25; 2 Tim. ii. 8. Eusebius uses the expression φασί, “they say,” which seems to imply that
the interpretation was a common one in his day. Schaff (Ch. Hist. I. p. 649) says that Origen also thus interpreted
the passages in Romans and Timothy referred to, but he gives no references, and I have not been able to find in
263
The First Successors of the Apostles.